And literally everything I tried to do to move the conversation forward has been undone.
Sigh. Have fun with the hissy fits and back and forths saying nothing.
And literally everything I tried to do to move the conversation forward has been undone.
Sigh. Have fun with the hissy fits and back and forths saying nothing.
All of your “points” have already been addressed by others besides myself.
Scroll up.
I need a break from the mental quicksand.
yeah this guy’s read-only, just reverts to what he was saying before he was corrected over and over
step one: walk in on people agreeing that FS should update their policy, for various reasons.
step two: disagree on all accounts, and call people too dumb to understand the given policy.
step thee: condescendingly point out you wouldn’t need an update, but agree anyway.
step four: …
step five: profit?
Pretty sure it’s write-only.
Hey, I heard you have a video of some sort to share, can you post it?
You’re right the Devs removed it for that reason, but its still a wild take IMO.
I haven’t used mods since day one and have not had a single game that had a conversation about score comparing. Most of the whining and complaining or “elitism” comes during the game when players go down or things start to fall apart. Once the game is over its a dash to leave the lobby.
I also still play V2 regularly and the green circles are honestly not a problem. Just look at damage taken and damage delt, everything else is moot.
back to the OP, I do agree that mod support should be limited to remove the blatant cheats, I wouldnt know any since Im a vanilla bean, but I wouldn’t want all of them removed.
Mods have always been an integral part of games to help communities grow.
Legitimately one of the most unhinged takes I’ve ever seen, lmao.
At this point…A Mod just needs to close this. It’s dissolving into way more toxicity than is supposedly allowed on the Forums…
I agree.
Nothing will come from the discussion.
Even the part of the community that complain about mods are not agree:
At the end, we cannot discuss. We have no real inputs from all these posts except that a part of the community wants to complain about how Fatshark handle mods. And finally, we have no solution proposed.
I profit of this post to point that I did a poll. I tried my best to put all options proposed. But, as always when I ask questions, when I tried to ask what was proposed, I never get a clear answer (as what happened here).
Nevertheless, the poll is NOT closed. You can even modify your vote. please voice your opinion, as a forum user, in it.
The actual result (for first question) is:
Feel free to voice your opinion, at least by voting in it. It takes 5 minutes.
People were discussing things just fine.
Even the community who doesn’t agree about mods has different opinions on it. It’s almost like a community is made up of various people.
As I specifically list things like Spideysense giving you full awareness even when it should not be possible. Plus others like the special tracker or the Minimap mod.
I listed multiple examples. Are you just going to straight up lie at this point?
You cannot. That is not the same as nobody being able to.
You seriously think that these mods change totally the effectiveness of a player? that magically he will be able to deal with every threat of the game cause he has just to follow indications on screen?
Well, that’s your opinion. Fine. As I tested it, and said it, I perfectly know that it is not what happens. The point where I would agree with you is the attack on back, that you cannot see, and that the mod can warn you about (and still you hear a sound or spidey sense would not work, so not even this example works). But even that, would it impact my experience? I can’t even know or be sure if someone is using spidey sense.
The special tracker I tested it also. It gives you the number of specials around. Great… again… is it impacting directly my experience if someone use it (cause I don’t)? I think the same. I would not be able to notice it.
When I ask a list it is to avoid to read 428 posts here and more in other threads. Is it so hard to list the mods you feel as crossing the line? And of course, I would need to do that for every users that seems to disagree with how fatshark handle mods. For now, you seem to be 2 in this thread that follow actively the discussion.
I just point the fact that nobody has been able to make a simple list. When someone has opened a thread about mods they use, I could easily post my own list of what I think as really good mods.
Is it so difficult to just state what are you pointing as mods that cross the lines? You spend more time at explaining that it is obvious (no it is not), that everybody knows what we are talking about, than the time that would needed to give the said list.
I am not the one that refuse to answer simple questions.
What do you propose as a solution of your problem?
And vote here if you didn’t. This can also help to understand the different opinions.
At least, you gave me a definition. But the definition is totally subjective (like the one of gpkgpk). That’s why a list can help to understand what we talk about.
I literally just did.
The only other one that comes to mind off hand is the health bar mod but I don’t think it’s as much of an issue overall, if only due to the fact that it bloats the screen and player damage is so high overall that it’s generally less of a benefit. (Which goes back to overall balance being dogshite right now)
Stop saying this. Seriously. People have answered your questions repeatedly.
Not my job. This is yet another common tactic people use to try to shut down criticism. Recognizing issues is not the same as needing to come up with solutions. Game devs exist for a reason.
I did. I also told you that poll was very flawed there as well.
No, a list just puts targets on specific things to go after while ignoring overarching issues. See: How frequently the discussion has gotten overly focused on things like Spideysense in particular.
Holy crap dude. Read people’s posts.
Yes of course. How could it be any other way? I’m sure even most modders agree.
Every gameplay mod boils down to one thing = making the experience easier (although the word ‘easier’ may trigger some and so they replace it with ‘convenience’ or ‘streamlining’ etc, but it’s still making things easier for that player).
Even if under the guise of bug fixes, it’s still making the game easier at its core.
Can’t hear all the trappers because of the bug we all experience? Installing the mod that points them out will make the game easier. I’m not arguing that bug is there to make things harder, but the mod, at the very basic description, makes the game easier.
Seeing health bars of enemies 100% makes the game easier because you can choose which enemies to prioritise and in what order.
Whether you agree with the mods or not, how can you possibly suggest they don’t affect the games difficulty?
Even the true level mod (arguably not a gameplay mod) affects level of difficulty because you’re removing a layer of engrained teamate RNG. Whether this is allowable or not is beside the point, and the point is that it all effects the difficulty of the core game.
No games studio in their right mind would ever conceive of testing and balancing a game with mods active because they, very literally, modify the core experience.
You did… not the other one that still maintain a subjective discussion.
So, the list is spidey sense, special tracker, mod that use animation cancellations and healthbar.
Already stated that animation cancel should receive a fix. A simply action queue would solve that.
Spidey sense and special tracker I have given my opinion. Healthbar is the same. I would not even notice it, I feel also that it can help you to understand the game, and if you know your weapons, healthbar mod is just an horrible thing that don’t really help you. But even if, will it change the DPS you can deal with your character? no. So, it doesn’t impact the game experience.
Again, just my opinion. I have understood you disagree. And get it, I am fine with the fact you disagree.
Thanks. At least we know that you expect nothing from them and just want to complain about the situation.
but spidey sense relies on sounds… and it can also miss special that don’t have sounds…
Cause I tested them? and without them it changes nothing?
Cause I think that the balance problems are more trivalizing the game than any current Nexus mod?
Cause I also see that you don’t need it to have the same efficiently.
But, here again, we will agree that we disagree
. But thanks for this input that summarize what you think about mods.
That’s true. However, if you start in the game it can also learn you, by example, that this is a bad idea to continue, with your zealot, to continue wasting your ammos on this crusher…
I only use healthbar mod in the training area when I use creature spawner. I often forget to unactivate it after that… and have to turn off at the start of the mission when I begin to see my screen full of healthbars. I really don’t think it change anything… again here, I have tested.
Thanks for quoting this one. Yes ESP mod. On gpkgpk list or not? don’t know…
Well, I think I voiced my opinion on these mods. My opinion is that, with the current Fatshark’s mod policy, none of the mods that were pointed in the last posts are directly impacting the experience of the 3 other players.
It could impact indirectly your experience, but directly, I totally disagree.
The other one has also been answered repeatedly.
Yes, those mods affect the difficulty. You are literally ignoring things that have been said to you already and then saying we can’t answer your questions. Literally my first reply in this topic to you.
And the follow up’s follow up.
ETC.
I’m at the point of thinking you’re trolling because hot damn.
Gonna quote myself:
It’s like you have a compulsive need to respond to every single response in the topic that’s critical of things.
EDIT because of yours:
You literally just proved my point for me. Way to try to immediately disregard my opinion because I’m not the one doing their job for them. Criticism is not synonymous with complaining. Learn the difference.
Yes that’s exactly the whole argument. Of course it’s indirect as it’s someone else’s mods affecting other players games.
I think we can all agree that effects would be felt indirectly. Indirect and direct is totally irrelevant as the end result would be the same for the other players.
And you testing a mod and making a decision about their level of disruption carries no weight whatsoever IMO. It’s just your opinion based on a single test case with no metrics and you’re a fervent mod supporter so how are we to guage your experience? We must look at it clinically and logically. I’m not trying to be rude but there’s just not a better way to say it. I mean no offence whatsoever.
We are discussing modifications. They are modifying the game experience. They are modifying the code. Pretty much any mod has the ability to affect difficulty in some way unless the mod is purely cosmetic (IE changing colour of your character skin). That’s just the basic logic to modifying code in a game. I’m not sure how it can even be up for debate tbh.
while not necessarily impacting others(apart from killsteal potential), it very much helps you conserve a lot of ammo, filter out ghost hits/limb shots and know exactly how many hits you need to finish something off and divert your focus elsewhere instantly before the damage goes through. mostly useful with DoTs and autoguns/recon
so yeah, it is far more cheesy in my view than decode helpers or spidey sense
Goodness me, this thread is still going? I’m guessing that and the course of its progression must come as quite the surprise to the OP.
Not that that matters of course. And while I’m doing the written equivalent of thinking outloud, I’d also like an ice cream sandwich.
No, they’re mine, get your own >:|
Never said the contrary ![]()
I have even said it loudly.
I don’t know if all will agree with you. And I know what YOU proposed by the past and I have put the only proposal I have seen in the poll I made (= your proposal).
I even agree that it would be a solution (and voted “I agree with this proposal”). They could make a list of mods that this part of the community feel acceptable and implement a switch that would allow to play with only players that use mods of this “white list”.
So, thanks again for the input. At least, this is clear. You said what mods are crossing your line in your opinion, you ask for a change about fatshark policy and you made a proposal.
This is the right way to contribute. Thanks again.