I don’t think it is that strong. I mean, it is a nice reserve of bombs but the reload time is quite prohibiting in clutch situations, and it isn’t very easy to aim at specials. The one time I thought it was very strong was with the reload speed on ammo pickup boon in the Chaos Wastes, next to an ammo box and against a monster. The FF is also quite a drawback.
So does Zealot, but he has less ammo sustain. The fact that they can be spammed by a BH with no counterpoint is absolutely boring, including for other players. And for people complaining about “being robbed of THP during hordes” by the Blunderbuss, they must absolutely hate the GF.
I think the Bretsword is very strong, but I don’t think it’s over the top. I really like the block on heavies gimmick, the moveset is very versatile and allows for dealing with most if not all situations, if anything it shadows the Halberd a bit - at least so long as Halberd’s heavies aren’t fixed.
Has anything changed on the Coghammer since release ? To me it still is the best of both worlds with 2H Hammer heavies on lights and Warpick uncharged heavies on heavies. Coghammer’s lights are fine as they have less damage and cleave than 2H Hammer heavies ; but the heavies are really strong, being warpick’s uncharged heavies with ~70% more armour damage.
You could add Mace and Sword though I’m not that big of a fan.
You also forgot the Deepwood staff which is not OP per se (though there is a weird interaction between crits, bleed on crits and the multiple projectiles - one left click with the staff consumes one stack of Morai-Heg’s doomsight but applies 4 bleeds…) but that has a very, very strong right click. I think it should cost more ‘overheat’ than it currently does, and its overheat system is objectively better than all of Sienna’s, with no drawback.
I’ve grown to hate the elf. I used ot think WS’s ult was stupid but now combined with everything else it’s just blown out of proportions…