Are there any Fatshark supporters after these months of Silence?

Studios develop and cultivate reputations, and the gravy train is ending. Studios are shuttered every week. As long as they deliver with their dlc and there are enough players through gamepass to justify the payments from MS, they are probably good financially, but reputations persist unless you deliver.

Honestly, HD2 is really excellent.
Missions are never the same. Off course you can see that this place is exactly the same of one you have already visited. But you choose your entry point, what you do as secondary, if you explore etc. I did a game where the support ship had left the closer orbit and so any death was a final sentence. That was great.
Stratagems are really top cool… when you use the orbital cannon in a desperate attempt, that’s look incredible (something I did yesterday with a guy on our position… that was vietnam war… but all bugs were killed and we had nothing to oppose to them)

BUT Darktide has the melee combat. There’s no melee combat in HD2. There is also no tactical positioning. I must say that Darktide implies certainly more skill and is really an adrenalin game.
HD2 is not quiet. You see enemies coming from everywhere, this is the WAR. Everything explodes around you… that’s insane. But it is a little less stressful than is Darktide where you have to not miss or it can be your last error.
There isn’t things like that. IF everybody die, they revive auto the players where in DT it would be the end. The game reward you even if you did not succeed to extract. DT reward you so little that it cannot be considered as a reward.

However… when I see that I can pay 20€ in this game for several weapons, armors etc… while this is the price of one cosmetic set in DT that has clipping problems and cannot be customized… well, When I see that the game has already launched 2 additions for the game… when I see the 2 totally different factions (must say Automaton seem a lot harder for me), when we see the freedom of HD2, the cool effects, the sum of weapons, the progression system…
Well yes HD2 is well done.

However, it can be good, it is not DT. There is no melee and this adrenalin I can feel while playing it,. However yes, I will play a lot HD2 cause this is really a good game.

This is the position everyone is sort of forced to take between the vacations and bugginess. I felt the previous tide games were borderline unplayable and had so much potential, but the other elements dragged it down. Ultimately Darktide is the same as they were for me: most of the best times are in the discovery of new encounters, not in the mastery of the content because it really doesn’t stand up to scrutiny. The bugs and inconsistencies are just too glaring.

The other thing that leaves me scratching my head is how the average developer / employee managed to keep working on a product that so routinely fails to live up to its potential.

I’m in a leadership position at a company that works on a range of public facing projects. If my staff poured their energy into things that were so poorly delivered and received by the public, and they were witness to all the criticism, I’d feel terrible about myself as a leader. I’d know it was affecting the morale of our staff and I’d be concerned about that. Talent leaves in these situations.

The average FS dev must just punch in and punch out with their head in the sand, staying oblivious to everything going on in the broader community. I don’t get it.

I have a feeling they have pretty high turnover. Would explain why they continuously need to ‘re-learn’ stuff. Plus if your management is stupid enough to create these problems, it’s not going to be a good work environment in general.

this actually made me laugh out loud

You are missing the point of this thread. It is fine and, in fact, I expect developers to take breaks and vacations from developing games - they deserve off-time, and it actually does improve the quality of the game since they come back with a fresh mind and new ideas.

What I am disappointed in is their failure to communicate when they are taking these holidays, taking said holidays when there are numerous bugs in the game that severely impact gameplay, and making very vague statements so they don’t have to back up on anything and say “sorry for not delivering”.

A few reasons I can come up with. I recently worked in a warehouse that was an overall nightmare and treated their customers in a comically poor way. Messing up order after order for a million dollar account and so forth. Keeping people on that are accident prone, get high, drink on the job, wear headphones on a forklift and drive too fast, crashing into objects on a daily basis, this type of thing. The company and personal culture was one of consistent negligence, not just the usual lack of accountability.

It was unthinkable for me and most of my friends and family to allow this behavior that encourages injury and death, plus adding the overhead of inefficiency and increased costs of insurance that come along with them. This type of behavior, especially the inefficiency, destroys many businesses.

They happened to have a business model and strategy that time favored, especially covid. When the factories shut down they had more overstock than anyone else, and this allowed them to have ever increasing profits and grab customers while their competitors failed. Sometimes it’s just that simple.

In the case of FS, i’d guess that they live in a country that openly discourages competition. That is, the government forces all of these regulations that hamstring production and customer service anyway, and they decide to lean into it for the tax status, incentives, and lifestyle it allows them to have. Not only do they fall into a niche that they appear unaware is increasingly shrinking, but they probably also have a rule that they can’t hire foreign people for customer service during their forced downtime and maintain their incentives. I would bet a lot of money that their income is subsidized. To be honest, this is the largest source of confusion for people like you and me on this forum: why hasn’t their business failed yet? How can they aggressively erode their customer base, even with MS cameos subsidizing it?

If you test out a few economics books until
you find one with a style you like that won’t put you to sleep, they go over some of these things. There also have the added bonus of making you laugh at politicians on a daily basis. I can send you some names if you’d like. The added ability to deflate arguments also makes you a huge hit at parties.

I think I’m in the running for longest off topic BS posts.

The mind boggling part is that Fatshark has local competition, literally just a short walk and a few blocks away is Arrowhead Studios who just dropped Helldivers 2 to an order of magnitude more success than Darktide. They’ve dropped more content in 6 weeks than Darktide has in 6 months.

Yet despite seeing that success every day just a short jaunt away, or at the bar after work, during lunch, at nearby events, etc, it doesn’t seem to have any impact on Fatshark. No competitive impetus has been imparted, no best practices rubbed off, etc.

There’s definitely no melee combat, but that’s not a huge deal for me personally. The game isn’t so much about your own positioning, more the teams positioning. Since missions aren’t on rails and the world is open, it’s a lot more about how you approach and engage a enemy base or objective and manage your trek across the battlespace with limited time. The “skill” comes from different places. Twitch shooting and melee combos and micropositioning aren’t really where the depth comes in, that part is much flatter in HD2, rather it’s the larger tactical picture. Higher difficulties become extremely skill dependent and require some coordination as you literally cannot fight everything, you have to avoid enemies and pick and choose your fights and avoid creating noise that attracts and generates new patrols, and avoid splitting teams as that will generate more enemies as well. That said, it’s definitely much more forgiving in general in the sense that it’s harder to straight up fail entirely and lose due to being able to constantly Reinforce (even if the entire team wipes) where that’s really not possible in DT.

It’s not that they don’t have comparable competition, it’s that some of the systems in place along with their specific market make it difficult to fail. Is there a better or more successful visceral physics based melee combat pve game?

When I worked in the warehouse there was another issue I ran into. If you strive to be the best you can be and look at your customers like your lifeblood, you’ll never really understand or accept people that don’t. Perhaps more importantly, they not only misunderstand you, but also fear your drive as a destructive force for good reason: you make them obsolete.

I don’t think people really want to spend all their time being negative but it’s hard to talk about good things coming up when Fat Shark repeatedly trips over itself and misses out on easy wins.

This isn’t really an issue of there being a tight deadline, this is a management issue of the right hand not understanding what the other hand is doing.

It should not be that hard to go “hey, here is some wip stuff” since Warframe does it all the time and so do other developers. Even if you don’t have anything I feel like setting expectations of going “yeah update this week” only to completely miss your own deadline is silly to say the least.

This should have been an easy PR win but instead you have people once again asking what is even going on at fat shark.

Yes, Dying light 1. And i would say combat against human enemies is more interesting than in tides, but could be a matter of taste.

Yeah, I agree. It’s not quite as a crazy nuanced and detailed as Darktide - but as far as combat mechanics, especially movement, and FPS games go, dying light is pretty damn good IMHO. I actually had a lot of fun with DL1, some of the challenges were really excellent. I like the dichotomy between day and night, the balance of being sneaky vs. aggressive, the open world environment, all of the parkour movement. The expansion with the dune buggy vehicles was a lot of fun too.

I haven’t bit the bullet on DL2 yet - maybe I’ll give that a try to 'tide me over (pun fully intended).

Take caution. Combat took a major hit in DL2. When i played it, it was just absolutely awful. They did update it since i last played but no idea if its as good as DL1 or they just put a small kiddie band aid on it and called it a day. Try to lower your expectation when you start it so that you dont get too disappointed.

Yes me. In my opinion the game will be perfect by 2029. Also none of the promises they made were their promises it was just mistranslations by the journalists. Also I believe everything every official Fatshark announcement/plan says despite it being incorrect and later forgotten 90% of the time (singleplayer mode is coming guys, we just need to wait on them to flesh out the bots first!)

Have been playing and posting less here because the GOAT Dragon’s Dogma 2 (which also failed to meet it’s true potential lol) got my attention at the moment.

That said I still believe Darktide will be amazing post crafting rework and with new content… But it’s gotta come and something has to give, obviously.

It’s not like it’s some sudden change. Fatshark always been like this. And yet they made V2 that is very much loved. They take a while to do things properly, but when it’s done, it’s usually very good. With that being said, more comminucation would be very nice, but I doubt that with the general toxicity of this playerbase they’ll decide to open up anytime soon

VT2 has the same player retention problems DT does, in that it lost 90%+ of its playerbase launch, did so very quickly, and never recovered it. The only people still playing are the die-hard fans. For 2024 so far, VT’s average online number of players has been sub 3k. FS has a history of releasing underbaked and unready products, taking the preorder cash, and leaving them in poor states for years. Their games tend to get lots of launch players and then drop off like rocks soon thereafter.

You don’t get to complain about the toxicity of the playerbase or the conversation around the game when you actively choose not to participate, shape, or inform it. Especially not when the studio just a few blocks away is pumping out content on the weekly, talking on all sorts of community platforms, and routinely has literally 100x as many online players to show for it.

Dying light is one of the greatest games ever made, but the parkour is actually what makes it better than Darktide. FS needs to figure out action queing.

With all respect, I get to complain about whatever I want. Those complaints don’t become less valid just because I personally am not trying to clean out the cesspit. And on the topic of HD2 and Arrowhead, you really don’t have to come up with examples of studio doing a better job. We all know Fatshark could be leagues better. My point is that Fatshark eventually make interesting games that are fun to play. And I personally don’t care about whether it’s 3 thousand or 300 thousand people, as long as there are enough people to fill the queue

Also, not that it matters a whole lot, but Arrowhead had 7 years to prepare a lot of content to “pump out on the weekly”, so both games aren’t exactly in the same position