When I, along with many other people, write the reviews for Winds of Magic as a DLC, Iām analyzing whatās in the game now and whatās not in the game. While I appreciate the effort and dedication to Winds of Magic at some level, I hope you understand that I am not writing āwell thereās some cool stuff coming in Decemberā as part of the review. If Iām still around to change the review in December, that stuff may cause me to change my recommendation significantly. But, in many cases, players donāt stick around to postpone judgment on something and adjust their reviews accordingly. As weāve seen with the base gameās negative reviews as of late, players arenāt even postponing judgment about the gameās state until WoM is officially released.
Look at No Manās Sky, for an extreme example. From what I hear, the game is actually not too bad nowadays. The gameās updates didnāt just wipe out the 50,000 negative reviews for the game regarding its earlier state. Thatās something the game had to work through for quite some time.
What is probably going to get a mention in the review for WoM? Probably some positive things for sure about the new map, the new weapons, and etc. What else is going in:
-
Thereās no Twitch mode for Beastmen and thereās no Cataclysm Deeds, which kinda shows how the update callously disregards those two systems by not interacting with them at all.
-
Thereās no extra loot for playing Cataclysm. Currently, I have more fun playing Twitch Legend and I get more loot than Cataclysm.
-
Thereās no new weapon illusions available to the regular mode, no new character skins, and no new hats. Thereās a smattering of portrait frames to unlock for the Weaves, Cataclysm, and the new map.
-
The Okriās Challenges for Cataclysm give commendation chests for beating Legend challenges on Cataclysm, when beating them on Legend gives Emperorās Vaults and a cool portrait frame.
-
The tedium, the grind of unlocking my weapons to experiment in the Weaves. How I have to pay Essence to unlock a different weapon and then use more Essence to make it good enough to use.
-
The progression pace of the Weaves.
-
The fact that my friends have to buy the DLC to join the new game mode, so I have difficulty progressing normally through the Weaves without bots, friends, or random players regularly joining.
-
The static nature of the Weaves, so thereās significantly less replayability unless youāre trying to speedrun to compete for a better time.
-
The Beastmen seem almost omnipresent on maps once you get the DLC, so you look for safe-havens like Into the Nest and Skittergate for a change of pace because they feel significantly harder than the regular enemies.
Now a lot of the things above are up-in-the-air right now, so theyāre subject to change between now and Tuesday. Itās a pre-release beta, and Iām probably not even going to write my review until at least after Iāve experimented with the released version over the next weekend.
Whatās not going into the review? The things that are āon the tableā for next season. The things that are āsomething weāre looking intoā. The things that are ābeing consideredā. Iām not writing the review based on anything you say is in season 2 or season 3 or season 8, just like I didnāt write āgoing to add dedicated serversā or āpotential to add new characters/classesā in my review for the base game. Iām not writing the review based on the untapped potential of the Weaves, because I could write very good things in general about the gameās potential, but thatās not what a review is for. Itās for the current state of the product being reviewed.
Thatās my perspective. If Iām still getting a lot of bugs and crashes, I may adjust my recommendation of the base game itself as well, but I want to review the Winds of Magic for the content thatās there, not the content that could be there. If the content here now isnāt capturing me, Iām not going to be enticed by the future content.
Thatās all. I am glad from the other post that thereās no significant crunch to force a lot of change and work to scramble in the update. Iām glad the work-life balance is okay. Iāll consider that when writing the review in a positive way. I appreciate the effort you all are putting in the game.