yeah, Fatshark really need to provide some solutions, the wild west approach with mods def doesn’t work but can’t leave the game with barebone QoL options
That’s another important aspect.
Is an autofire mod technically a cheat. I could be convinced that it is. A macro for optimal attack speeds is pretty much the same thing.
I don’t see it as a cheat because it helps you not get stress injuries such as carpal tunnel syndrome.
And what skill are you replacing? Spamming the left mouse key with input buffering in place? Who the hell cares? I’d care more about not permanently f*cking up my tendants and if someone wants to give me sh!t for that… f×ck em!
well some allow way faster attackspeeds that are just not humanly possible that where the problems come in
Thats a cancel block cancel macro which are banned such as m1 spam on psyker staves and rashad l1 spam
For me, such things fall in the exploit domain. I repeat, this is only my opinion.
However, I think that this has to be corrected IN GAME, cause I think we are all doing macro cancelling without even wanting it.
As I did not test this mod, I won’t comment more. I just wanted to comment your sentence.
Anyone can swap a staff to shoot faster but the macro makes you do it inhumanly fast thats why its banned.
tldr fatshark has unofficialy banned complex macros and you can get reported if you staff spam
Thank you for a reasonable take on the discussion. I’m not against autofire conceptually, I also hate RSI and having to spam M1 on infantry las etc. Macros that allow superhuman fire rates are absolutely cheating, by definition. If the autofire mod does not allow unreasonable fire rates, then I’m fine with it, but I also wouldn’t be surprised to learn there are variants of that mod that do. I also agree that a basic level of autofire should be in the vanilla game for those weapons that benefit from it, if only so they can be limited to reasonable rates.
Spider sense (I assume that’s the threat indicator mod) seems to me to be cheating, as no other players have visual threat indicators. But again, I agree that the sound issues should be fixed - I’ve been subject to silent bursters etc. too and I find it hugely annoying.
That’s good to know, thanks.
I did not say that mod = cheat. I said that mods that provide a player with advantages another does not have are cheats. There is no rational way to defend one player having visual threat indicators that hugely assist situational awareness while others do not.
Whether it was developed for a deaf person is irrelevant, it provides those benefits to anyone that uses it, which in turn affects the players who join squads with that mod user (as do all mods that provide gameplay advantages that others do not have).
By your logic an autoaim mod would be fine because it would assist a blind player.
Could happen that there is too many sounds in the buffer to let them play all.
But, when the sound is not here at all, Spidey sense won’t help you.
When I tested it, I faced several times specials that have not been seen byu the mod.
Totally agree. And let’s not forget to say that the mod is useful for a player that has an hearing impairement or even for someone that don’t use a good headset.
The mod itself won’t make you a god… it won’t help you priorise targets, won’t make you aiming better etc.
I’m aware of that difference. All I was saying was that I can see someone make that claim and that there is at least some merit to it.
The nuance here is what makes one a cheat and the other a QoL, stress injury prevention mod.
You didn’t outright say it but with your train of thought, you might as well have.
And I already outlined how that is wrong.
I have already given you the rationale for that mod. I have tried the mod myself and I have not found it to help. I still got silent trapped with it and I was still aware of 98% of specials both with and without it. Most of the time I didn’t even look at the indicators. The only time I was able to look at the indicators was when I would’ve had enough time to check for specials anyways.
Why would it be irrelevant? The intent and inspiration for the mod obviously matters to the conclusion of whether it’s a cheat or not. It’s just more convenient to your point if it wasn’t relevant.
I’m not going to pretend that the mod isn’t beneficial to have and that it can’t be used by people that it wasn’t made for, even if i personally haven’t felt like it made me win more.
But to a good player…
This holds ture. Especially now that audio files load faster. I absolutely notice the difference now and I tested spidey sense after the audio update and it doesn’t help a single bit.
Also, how would you be able to tell that someone else is using that mod? You realistically can’t.
That’s a false equivalency.
Again, it sounds like that’d make sense but it doesn’t and it’s not the same.
Autoaim already exists on console and nobody is calling that an advantage of theirs.
A blind person couldn’t win by having autoaim because having good aim isn’t everything you need to win.
I could also give spidey sense to someone who’s bad at the game and they wouldn’t start winning missions they otherwise couldn’t.
I’ve also had issues with finding players in VT2. I don’t know why, maybe there’s a setting wrong somewhere, but last time I had to play solo. There were only ten lobbies and they were all in China.
As I recall there were selections on the launcher modded/unmodded, so maybe I had the wrong one selected.
My point was more that he said that DT would be dead with 1500 players and VT2 had less players than that and wasn’t dead.
1500 is more than enough to find players. I’ve found matches at all times, not just during the day. All that changes is their ping.
It would be interesting to know why you guys are having trouble.
I play only on legend and cata and live in europe. I played with other europeans, americans and chinese and japanese players, even outside of their main gaming hours. Even had some australians and they are literally on the other side of the planet for me.
This assumes Fatshark sees “cheat” the same way as you do.
To use the example of the DecodeHelper, this can help you minimize the time spent on the minigame, but Fatshark designed the encounter to take a minimum amount of time, and you cannot bypass that. It can help reduce the time you spend on that obstacle and out of the fight, but that’s about it, you’re still going to have to sit there and operate the scanner and wait for the scan element to reach the right characters and press them at the correct time.
As far as FS has been concerned, that appears to be fine.
I’m not sure i’d pull that conclusion. Possibly they don’t think it’s fine but don’t care enough to do something about it. If you look at how the minigame on the train mission works, it interestingly takes a set amount of time minimum, enforcing the “gameplay break” dynamic, as opposed to the old minigames like scan targets or the hab dreyko thing, which were designed before these mods emerged and can be trivialized and vastly sped up by them.
It’s one of these things that are kinda sad from a game design perspective, if intentional. I think the train mission minigame is decidedly worse than scanning or the other gameboy minigames.
I’ve mentioned it elsewhere but gameplay design in WoW boss fights changed entirely because there are very few limits to what addons can organize and automate on behalf of the player. This obviously isn’t as impactful, it’s just some mechanics to make you spend time and multitask and split attention in an enemy-filled event, but I think that it’s the same design issue.
Simply put if mods trivialize your current systems then you can either hunt the mods or the systems must change. Sometimes the former would result in a better game.
I wonder how many ways we can go down the route of:
“They haven’t taken it down so it’s fine.”
“Fatshark has no control over Nexusmods nor does not removing something equal acceptance.”
“They haven’t taken it down so it’s fine.”
FWIW: You can also reset the puzzle if you exit and retry, so if you glance a pattern with all edges, trade it for a quicker one.
I know what some others think this, why do you?
Using a controller isn’t hard lol you make out like its impossible i have beaten havoc 40 on console with a controller and obviously no mods ![]()
Looking at the mod policy:
Using mods that directly affect unmodded players’ experience of the game and/or is used to grief other players.
Examples: Speed hacks, outright cheating in missions, etc.
Using mods that affect the stability/performance of the game service.
Using mods that devalue other players’ investments (time or monetary) in the game
Examples: Bypassing progression, penances or contracts, unlocking of premium cosmetics and currencies in the game service.
Toxic behaviors reported as an indirect result of using mods.
It’s not like a speedhack or outright cheat in the sense that it doesn’t do anything that just being really good at the minigame doesn’t do, you still have to beat the minigame, you can’t bypass it. That’s what I get from reading that.
So while the mod may feel “cheaty”, it doesn’t fall into what Fatshark appears to consider a cheat in a sense that they’re concerned with.
Going from there, it doesn’t appear to affect stability or performance. It doesn’t directly “devalue other player’s investments” i.e. won’t unlock pennances or premium cosmetics for you. It doesn’t appear to generate toxic behavior in the sense that people aren’t slagging each because they completed minigames too fast (and it’s not doing something like spamming voice emotes).
Looking at Fatshark’s actions, they have all the power in the world to alter the mechanic or slap in a different minigame, to break the mod, ask for the mod to be taken down, and to make announcements and discipline players for use. They have done none of the above to date with regards to DecodeHelper.
Hence my arrival at the conclusion that it appears to be fine as far as FS is concerned. With the evidence and policies available, I’m not sure what other conclusion we could arrive at. If FS does not think its fine, they’re doing everything they can to make people think otherwise given how long the mod has been publicly available, it’s not something they can say they just didn’t know about.
Aye, the minigame on the train is different and enforces a lot more time out, but I’m not sure how much we can call that adapatation to mods vs just experimenting and playing with different things on new maps. Fatshark certainly could have patched the older missions to use a different minigame if they were that concerned however.
Your information might be severely out of date (this has all been said before).
That’s now how the mod is used or intended really, if it was, to your point you could argue that it was a at least form of accidental balance and I’d agree with you.
An intentional effort was made to make it highly customizable, so to that you can focus on specific threats at specific threat thresholds (ranges, actions)
, e.g. disablers and pox if you can’t hand the additional information on-screen.
e.g.
sample snippets, where’s all that visual clutter?
TLDR: any “clutter” is highly customizable in your favor, and/or you get used to processing new advantageous information.




