Disable end of match vote kicking

I suppose cause of situations when people kick someone cause they need a room for a friend. Sometimes they politely ask to leave, but sometimes person who was asked are not going to do it just because or he don’t speak english or whatever.

I am not sure about other situations but I know in my family member’s situation, they wern’t even asked if they could leave. It was a vote kick out of the blue. I was watching as this all happened

My family member qued as quick play. This wasn’t a private lobby or anything. They just clicked the play button and found out 10 mins they got kicked. 10 mins is a waste of time to people like us who work a lot. We get nothing out of it

As for Ralendil… The problem is that the system is already abused heavily. By adding a hardcode to it, there is the opportunity for someone to rarely get a lobby if people “tag team” the person. So if you did that, you would have to ensure that the vote kickers are punished as well (for abusing the system)

I was first person in the ship. After last battle was over I ran to ship as they all sat in last room, because instead of trying to get in and leave, they were all chatting in their discord and vote kicking me for suggesting they use a med kit to not die.

Agreed, seems such an easy fix.

  1. Cant kick someone last 15% or so of the map because obviously if they havent been kicked by then, they were a good or at least passable teammate and to kick them after that is just to do it to abuse the system.

  2. Once 3 people are inside extraction point, a timer starts and last person has 60 seconds or so to make it in there and join them before it takes off without them.

Stops abusing people by kicking them after using them entire match and stops abusing by idling to keep game from ending.

Well that is depressing to know they went through this and solved it already and yet, here we are. :persevere:

No. Someone not being kicked before any arbitrary point in the mission does not equal to them being a passable teammate! Not everyone has the same tolerance for having to pick up someone elses slack.

What if they needed to be carried for the first 85% and then started to grief you in the last 15%? Do they still deserve to finish that match? What stops them from doing that?

You know damn well that people that want to troll will simply wait until there are no consequences for their actions anymore to then do it.

Also, why exactly 15% remaining before vote-kick is tunred off? Why not 50% or even 70%? You can easely tell if someone is good enough for the mission by the first serious combat encouter. Sometimes you can tell just by their loadout.
The point here is that at which arbitrairy %ige the voting turns off, doesn’t matter. With your logic, I can argue for any value being the correct one and it makes “just as much sense”.

Also, what exactly is “good enough” as to not be kicked? Why would anyone want to accept your arbitrairy standard to answer that question? Do you expect everyone to agree to a single standard and be objective?

The other point is that, with your logic, you should / have to kick anyone that you deem “not good enough” by the point before voting gets disabled. If you don’t then what is left to justify the point after which voting gets disabled? This implication is actually really toxic and would make the voting discussion so much worse than you seem to realize.
What if someone had a bad game and got unlucky? What if you’re trying a new build for the first time and don’t do so well? What if there’s one guy that’s doing bad but he’s playing with a friend so you can’t kick them even if it would adhere to your logic?

There is simply no correct solution as to when the voting should be disabled for far better reasons as to why it should be disabled at some point during the mission.

Again, you cannot prevent idiots form kicking you for no reason. If they want to kick you and you make it impossible after a certain point, guess what they will do?
The only way to truly prevent that, is to have no vote-kicking at all. I shouldn’t have to explain why that isn’t an option.

That you get kicked at the end of a mission is certainly annoying but it’s not such a massive problem that it needs to be fixed. Nevermind the fact that there is no good fix for that to begin with or that implementing such a fix doesn’t have more downsides, more often, than upsides.

Well, playing with just a single friend makes that impossible but I won’t pretend like that’s the solution.

Realistically, how often does this happen to someone? I’ve never seen it once in 2400h of VT2 and DT combined.

Just happened to me.
So predictably the stealth zealot ran ahead the entire map, never pinged a single mob, never helped anyone, went down a couple of times as he was soooo far ahead and caused his other 2 buddies to go down almost wiping the match a couple of times, facetanking the elevator , triggering crusher pats etc.
I asked him to slow his roll a few times finally I asked how you get to be overlevel 191 and still do stupid things like this.
Well turns out they’re all steam friends, from Canada no less.
Got votekicked, I saw it coming too when 1 of 'em didn’t move all of a sudden.
The most surprising part is he has 2 buddies that play with him like this.

So good enough to not be kicked is pretty self explanatory, it means no one tried to kick them before the end of the match because they were a good or at least decent teammate. Kicking someone at the very end of the match is never done for any legitimate reason other than they wont get in extraction point.

Anything else is done to be a troll by little immature kids that think its funny. After 200 or so hours in this game I have never once had someone be a great teammate all match and then just go troll at very end for no reason, only thing close is I have seen people just keep fighting even though match is over and not get in dropship. Yet I have heard dozens and dozens of people say that this situation that has happened to me has happened to them as well and some say multiple times. Fatshark acknowledged this is a problem they are working on and said it would be addressed so obviously its a problem, just not a problem you care about.

Seems your entire post was just arguing for the sake of arguing as both solutions I suggested would fix both of these problems. Thanks for your input of nothing needs to be fixed and you have no solution to fix any of the issues you list anyways.

I dare you to read my first message to this thread.

200h is not very long I’m afraid to tell you but that’s besids the point. You wanna know why you’ve never seen someone do that? Because they can be kicked at any moment. I’ve seen it a few times in VT2 and not once in DT…

And all I see are strawmen.
Dozens and dozens? Where did you find them, a post asking for anyone to confirm if X situation has happend to them? You know, a place where you would find an absurdly high concentration of said experience which is in no way representative of how often it actually happens?

There millions of matches played each day and even if you’ve heard of all of these occurances in just a single day, it would still be 48 < X’000’000.
I’m not the best at math but that doesn’t look like a particularly big problem to me.

Where and when has FS acknowledged this problem? That’s a serious question, not trying to suggest that they haven’t.

I care about the fact that this is very much so a very small minority occurance and the only few times I had to kick someone because they deserved it, had to be at the end of the mission.

Ah yes, the common “I don’t care for the points someone else makes if they disagree” argument.
You completely missunderstand where my argument and points come from and just dismiss them because I don’t agree with your stance.

It’s funny that you suggest to have read my messages but your responses prove that you didn’t understand a single one. You’re not even trying to argue against my points with logic. You do what almost everyone else does too, ignoring the actual points and just say whatever you come up with to back your previous points.

This 2nd half even confirms what I said above; you don’t care for the arguments someone else makes, you only see that it’s not in agreement and then dismiss what else was said. It also proves that you didn’t actually understood what my points were.

The solutions to the points I raise is that vote-kicking should stay on for the entire run of a mission?!? I even explain how all that is linked.
Besids, they are questions directed at your fix. I don’t need to convince myself of your solution, you need to be able to do that.

My entire argument boils down to this:

Yes, being kicked at the end of a match, especially when it’s done maliciously, is annoying. That much I acknowledge.

What I don’t acknowledge is that your fixes actually fix this issue and I point out that there are more than just a few new problems those fixes create and nobody has yet been able to argue against the points I raised.

All I’m saying is that this not just an easy “do A to make B go away” problem to solution relationship. A has problems C through G and were ignoring those because “I was kicked once so problem B is more important, / C through G have never happend to me so they aren’t real, damn you!”

There is only two reasons to behave in a match in DT: ones own desire to not be a d!ckhead and the fact that you can be kicked if you decide to be an asswipe.
Take the 2nd away at any point and you will see people take advantage of that. I’ve seen it happen plenty of times in VT2 and not once in DT.