Thanks dude, but now, after spending more than a month at the forum, I think all this stuff here is irrelevant, and even implementing all those paragraphs is not gonna change anything in the long run due to one and one factor only, that FS needs to fix. I think their main problem is much more fundamental and has nothing to do with any particular game flaw - it is lack of respect to their players, people, which pay them money, support them and are the sole reason their game and their company does exist. All of their other problems come directly from this simple fact.
When I composed this list, I never even though about anything like that. I used to be very naive: that was my first experience of communicating with an indie game company, and I thought I could change something, help make the game better, do something good to people, that gave me so much joy. I thought, that this statement:
as well as all other statements about feedback importance FS made, really meant something.
But the more time I spent at the forum, the more I doubted, that these things have something to do with reality. And removal of the roadmap was the last straw, that made me realize what the actual problem is, and also removed any empathetic feelings I had to FS. Cause not only they failed all the deadlines and all the pledges, but they also tried to hide this fact; and they made no official apology for this, not even a single statement, acting like nothing happened. And for me, that’s the worst thing they’ve ever done, because it shows how the company treats their players… well, like some inferior beings, that will just swallow any kind of attitude.
Don’t get me wrong, I am not trying to say that FS is filled with horrible arrogant people. I don’t know their hierarchy and their policy might be causes by a single person, being at the helm, or by a group of people. But all their promotional materials are presented in plural form, in such a way, that presents FS is a cohesive indie team, that is waiting for players’ feedback, will be glad to receive it and will certainly take it into account.
And that’s the most important, most fatal part of their policy. If you state such things, but do not follow them in reality, this is gonna backfire pretty soon and backfire hard. Seeing such statements, the most dedicated fans will surely get hyped and support you very much at first. But as soon as they realize that all those declarations was nothing, but a marketing hook, they will face deep frustration and you will simply lose them.
And that’s no joke. Losing community core is disastrous. Fans do so many things for their loved gamed on pure enthusiasm, which no one will ever do for any amount of money. This this includes but is not limited to mods, that fix game flaws, guides and newbie help, free internet promotion and just moral and material support, which you can’t achieve anything without.
If FS ignored their players from the very start, that wouldn’t be a big deal - every game company acts like this nowadays. But their disrespect to the players is caused by the fact, that they gave a lot of hopes and promises to them at first, and then screwed them up. And not just players in general, but the most devoted and faithful of them. And THAT is the biggest problem FS has right now, not patches, money or anything. FS also does some other things, that show their disrespect to players, like complete lack of any feedback on players’ problems, but these things are fully overshadowed by previous paragraph.
I can’t predict the faith of Vermintide 2. This is a unique game with unique gameplay, it’s core mechanic is very well done, and fanbase largely consists of good people, that are ready to forgive FS for their mistakes, if they get fixed. But the game surely received a hard blow, that will affect it for a very long time. And I am completely certain, that when making VT3 FS can’t afford doing any mistakes, cause people are alerted now, and will run away in case of any hints that VT3 has the same problems as VT2.
In conclusion, I’d like to share one lesson, that I learned for myself from the above situation - do not waste time and effort on good deeds, that you are not getting paid for. Very likely it will turn out, that the recipient doesn’t need your “good deed” and doesn’t even treat it as “good”. This happens, because very often what people want and what they state they want - is two completely different things; not to mention that your might have very different opinions on the subject. And also when doing something for free, your effort is ALWAYS valued much less. So is it really worth wasting your time? I personally don’t think so.