I don’t think we can report people for being overly passionate unless they start dishing out death wishes.
While I see the benefit of the suggested changes and your goal, I would also say it is the inherent weakness of it. It would make Riposte a talent which can only be utilized by a handful of people or simplified … very niche. Depending on stance this can be counted as both good or bad. Personally, I think something with a broader appeal is more interesting.
I would have a simpler suggestion (however which I assume you won’t like that much):
- Integrate Parry into Riposte (as I can see the “need” for this)
- Remove Crit properties from the game and replace them with another property (reducing the overall Crit Chance will make a talent with a certified Crit comparatively more attractive)