This game won't last... And this is coming from someone who loved the other tide games

Just pray that that KRUTTIN PIECE OF KRHAK stocks what you want! Yes, it was the weakest part of VT2, but it still felt more rewarding than in DT, where it STILL is the weakest part.

No, I do not remmeber that because I never crafted a new piece of equipment because “muh 10 power level difference” every 3 item drops.

I remember random chests… and they are better than what we have in darktide. At the very least as auxiliary. Especially considering that they allowed killing bosses (and collecting tomes and grims) to have a noticable, positive, effect at the end of the game, instead of being primarily a hassle.

And hten, there’s that fracking Emperor’s gift, whcih is in desperate need of a rework.

Here’s how I’d do it: It’s 100% Guaranteed at the end of a mission. However, the chances go, purely as example:

Grey - Very High/guaranteed… like 60%

Green - Medium 25%

Blue - Rare 10%

Purple - Very Rare 4.5%

Orange - Think about buying a lottery ticket/0.5%

Slightly hyperbolic, of course.

And every boss killed and every side objective completed improves the “base” level of the loot you get by one, and improves the chance for hte following levels.

So, getting a grey would be guaranteed with smaller and smaller chances for getting green, blue, purple and finally orange.

However, if you kill 2 bosses, you’re guaranteed a blue. If oyu also collect both grimoires, it’s a purple.

If you get 3 bosses and collect all scriptures, its guaranteed to be master crafted.

If you defeat 2 bosses, blue is guaranteed and the chance of getting purple (or orange

Vermintide also allowed the sharing of trinkets between characters which caused equipment power level on new characters to adjust tot hat. You didn’t have to start new characters from zilch… unlike Darktide where every character is completely and utterly divorced.

I dont think anyone believes vermintide 2’s grind was better, they are both appalling and should be lessened, the average player will not play 140~ hours, (average time spent to get to level 30 is about 35 hours x 4 for each class) they need the lessen the grind primarily for the sake for player retention

VT2s grind was better… in nuances.

VT2 allowed sharing of trinkets and as such immediate adjustment of the gear powerlevel, allowing you to “properly” play higher difficulties sooner.

The melee combat being mechanically worse, for one. If they didn’t gut the melee combat I actually wouldn’t be complaining about anything, I expected the bugs and poor performance and whatnot, that’s just Fatshark. The great melee combat they polished to a mirror sheen in VT2 being made worse was unexpected.

I want to touch on this on the fact that this is 100% incorrect, the average mission time in vermintide 2 on Legend (level4) was about 15-20 minutes, the longest and toughest mission on cata (level5) being roughly 30 minutes. Meanwhile in Darktide the average mission lengths on malice (level 3) is 25-30 minutes, and damnation (level 5) being roughly 45 minutes to an hour, literally longer than the triple mission excursion of chaos wastes from vermintide 2.

This is primarily because of the systesm that they have in place of searching for the tomes/grims, searching for crafting materials, and the very frequent ability to get multiple bosses in a run (verminitde its limited to 1 boss per run).

Yeah, while the option to work on maximizing your gear will be there, you can enter higher difficulties without the be best stats possible.

We don’t know what Darktide looks like on release yet because its release date is tomorrow. My understanding is that the last few weeks of play were a very limited window into the game to troubleshoot things like connection and scaling issues (hey that definitely worked) but I guess I could be wrong.

If someone doesnt believe me about darktide taking much longer then here is this

Here we have brae, a well known cata+ player from vermintide, one of the best of the best players, taking 36 minutes to do a level 4 run in Darktide

Vs

J_sat, one of the original vermintide True-Solo’ers teaching 3 players on their first level 4 run in vermintide 2, only taking 19 minutes

Better to have 15 half-baked careers than 4. As for those other issues: Fatshark solved them already in V2, so there’s no justification for them being present in Darktide. I see lots of people acting like Fatshark is building Darktide from the same place they were at when they built Vermintide 2, but that’s just… not applicable. They’re now sitting on the better part of a decade’s worth of design experience; the fact that almost none of those learned lessons found their way into Darktide should not be so lightly excused. It’s negligent at best, egregiously lazy at worst.

Me

You

Are you having a bad day?

Bit of a cherry pick. Fort Brachsenbrücke is one of the shorter levels on Vermintide 2.
I had 20 mins runs on Darktide, too. More so going by my feeling. But ye, those were pre-crafting update so I guess the searching for stuff does add up.
Technically speaking you can rush level 30 a lot faster here than in Vermintide, though. Plenty of people have done it with the Sedition speedrunning in ~10-15 mins. It’s not very fun, though. I will give you that.

Okay. I actually made an Account just so I could respond to this. While some say that what you wrote is valid criticism, and in some Points I agree, the way you are expressing yourself seems way too overblown.

To get some context:
I have a bad PC. Like, real bad. Don’t even know if I met the Minimum Requireds. My Internet sucks too, 240kb/s most of the time.
Couldn’t get more than 30fps, constantly got thrown out of matches because of high ping and needed to reconnect. Regular Freeze Frames. At least 5 hours out of my 50 Hour Playtime was waiting in Loading Screens, and that’s being generous.

But I can honestly say that I love this game. I like it way more than Vermintide and it’s Sequel. I haven’t had that kind of Fun in Years. The only thing that even comes close imho is Deep Rock Galactic, but even that can’t reach the kind of Excitement I had while playing, even though it’s running smoother.

Maybe you didn’t Play with Friends? The Gameplay, Coordination and Communication while playing on Heresy or Above is just hilarious. Even with a well-oiled Team that communicates and knows it’s stuff, it is challenging and extremely entertaining.
The amount of Chaos that ensues when getting overrun is something I have never experienced in that way before, and the possibilities you have to deal with said Chaos are also not limited to ‘I Block and Dodge and Hit, maybe throw a Ability in there’, like it was in Vermintide. You have the Ability to Compromise, you have more Granades, better Ranged Weapons, Vaulting, more in-depth Gameplay Mechanics with Traits and way better Map Design. The Ecstatics are on Point. The Atmosphere also feels way better than VT. And that’s being said with Graphics on Low, Fidelity on Performance, 18-30FPS and frequent Crashes.

I can see myself playing it hundreds of hours. Not to improve my equipment, but just for the Sake of the Experience. It’s challenging and complicated. May be a turn-off for some, to Fail 5 Times in a Row and to waste 160 Minutes or something like that. It really wasn’t for me though. Just made me want to play more.
I also like the RNG-Type Equipment System more than the Chest System from Vermintide. While opening Loot Boxes was fun and getting to Emperors with Ranald’s was super satisfying, it just got so boring and repetitive after some time. With this new System, you have the possibility of getting some minor Improvements and Changes, if you invest enough time at least.

I can understand that you are frustrated with the Game. You have the right to be, and I don’t want to say you can’t. But it seems insulting that you think, People who are like me or have similar Opinions, don’t exist. And I’m not only speakig for myself. A majority of my Friend Group, easily 10 People, think the same.
Sorry to say this, but saying that this Game won’t last just seems like a stupid Statement, honestly.

Played plenty with friends. None of my criticisms had anything to do with that, so I don’t know what you’re rambling about.

You say “better ranged weapons” and that already suggests that you honestly have no idea what you’re talking about. Most of the ranged weapons in this game are… frighteningly mediocre.

Your thoughts on the gearing system just don’t make sense either, I’m sorry. You were far more likely to be able to acquire (or craft) upgrades via vermintide, especially since you could actually CRAFT THE WEAPONS you wanted. In this game you can’t.

I get that you really like the game. And I had plenty of fun myself. I spent over 120 hours in the beta.

It just has GLARING balance issues and troubling design decisions that are going to turn a lot of people away, especially since the game will be released tomorrow half-baked and missing systems. There really is no defense of that. I’d take another delay over another broken release.

VT2 was much, much better though.

All of the overly positive credit this game is getting is really just new players to the series who love 40k.

It’s a shame that Fatshark will cater to these players more (i mean, they have to its a business), but the games harshest critics are the players that have played their games more than anyone. I being one of them.

“Psyker is useless on heresy and above, and it just feels like dogpoop to play. Most other classes only have one or two viable weapons.”

Straight up wrong.

“And, to be honest, most of them are too darn tanky. Mutants are the only ones that should be able to take a beating.”

Bad Equipment maybe? Or bad Teamplay with no calls? That’s why I assumed you didn’t play with Friends.

“Weeklies feel more like monthlies”

What? I literally got them all twice within a Day!

“Endless horde is perhaps the most annoying, DULLEST modifier to play, and it’s all that’s available 90% of the time.”

The only way to play below Heresy. Otherwise it’s boring. You should always keep moving, if you don’t, you get bogged down and expand too much resources. In what way does the Word “Dull” describe a situation, where you have more of something than normal? Annoying, I can understand, but dull just doesn’t fit at all as a description.

“Grims are stupid. they will literally reduce you to two health, and chip damage means that’s not even manageable.”

Didn’t have that kind of experience either. Just baffling that you played more than twice as much as me and still don’t understand basic Gameplay Mechanics…

“And I’m going to be honest, the ranged enemies and gunplay are cool, but you spawn TOO MANY of them TOO OFTEN.”

That’s exactly what I like. You need to be fast. Methodical. Your Aim needs to be on Point. Your Teamplay and Communication needs to be on Point. You need to use Cover and shift Positions. You need to Flank to get into Meele, and you need to do it smart, or you die instantly. Again, a Reason why I thought you played with Randoms.

To round this up, the other Points you brought up, I totally agree with. But to say that I’m rambling and don’t make sense, while writing the stuff you did, seems hypocritical. To say that I have no Idea of what I’m talking about, in that context, even more so.

You can’t craft Weapons? Such a loss… The Shop resets every hour! Just wait! Is that so hard?
Upgrading was never a Problem for me either. Just don’t throw all your resources out while being low level or not really needing to.
Where was the Full-Auto Shotgun in Vermintide? The SMG with nearly 100 Shots per Magazine? Where was the Plasma Rifle with Overheating Mechanics or the Rocket Launcher? Maybe I had a different experience due to my Circumstances, but I can’t agree with you at all in regards to the Statement, that the Weapons are Mediocre. Best Gunplay I had since… Idk, Squad probably. And that’s been Years. Even tough I had all the issues I listed above. Can’t enjoy a lot of Shooters I liked prior to the Beta. Just too damn boring now.
It seems to me that you are bitter, or that the Game just isn’t for you. When was the last Time a big Game released not Half Baked? “It takes Two” maybe? And we are not talking about EA or any other AAA Publisher, where we should get something like that! No, we are talking about Fat Shark! A Company known to release Games when they are poorly optimized, but also known to keep making said Games better and releasing free DLC’s, even after Years.
Criticizing them and giving good Feedback is very welcome. But what you wrote seems more like a Rant.

And to reiterate, it feels insulting and seems narrow-minded that you think there aren’t People who enjoy this Game like it is, or that it will die, even though you have Experience with their former Games. To say something like ‘there is no defense to that’, is stupid. Yes, there is! They will keep working on it. Like they did with their last few Games. That came out in way worse States and with way less Content than this one, by the way.
Also, it’s a Game! Why would they need to defend anything? They didn’t initate a War or directly cause harm. The only thing they have to do is make their Vison into a Format that they themselfs are satisfied with. That’s the only thing anyone has to do in life. Besides eating, shtting and dying. Why would anyone need to defend that? Because you payed something for it? Get over yourself, nobody forced you to!

Dude don’t engage. This guy’s one signature move is condescension, and he spams it like a casual fighting game player.

Umm they clearly listed out the levels you would have access to… how did anyone interpret that as “full game”???

Well, you’re incorrect. I played Vermintide 1, Vermintide 2 and now I play Darktide.
I’m pretty sure Darktide is going to be a perfection of the formula and have more depth than Vermintide 1 and 2.

I doubt his post is in reference to itemization and grind lmao, those are nowhere near the top of the list of problems that DT has.

I mean, if you define anything by what was done in the past, then nothing is truly that bad right now. But this is a case of the goalposts legitimately shifting without actually being a bad thing, and trying to bring up examples of games that aren’t even in the same genre from different generations of video game design evolution doesn’t help anyone or further a discussion.

Darktide is a grindy game. VT2 and VT1 were much worse, especially VT1 at launch. They were also very frustrating games.

From what we can see and what we know right now, Darktide is worse than VT2. That isn’t a good thing.