Temp health talent rework

[Darth_Angeal]

So first of all… why does everyone have to open a new thread? I´m pretty sure, that you wrote down your idea in this one:

Temporary Health - The Hidden Problem

Before we commence can I mention that a lot of the current threads here are about balance and this is very heartening for me. Usually, it’s glaring bugs, or huge imbalances, or ruthless mercenary AI that has dominated the discussions here and seeing many threads talking about balance rather than bugs is a bit of a confirmation that Fatshark is moving In the right direction > we’re all discussing balance now rather than bugs (on the whole) so it’s a bit of a boost to my flagging morale that FS a…

Everyone here and even FS will lose the overview about all ideas and the most ppl be meant to / will write the same things over and over again in every thread.

2nd:

@Arcter

• add 2 temp health on melee only kills talent

• add 1 temp health on ranged only kills talent

• crits proc 3 temp health for melee and ranged talent stays the same (or maybe gets buffed to 4)

This would be the same as before. Especially “melee something” benefits from the temp - health. Crit wouldn´t make it better, because dd´s with a high critchance (WS, pyro , BH, huntsman) will have a big advantage again the rest of the careers. + 3 of them already have…
And as long as some careers are able to kill about 90% of the enemies from the distance, the 1 health from range kills will last in a grey healthbar and nothing really changed.

This idea wouldn´t change anything as long as the ppl are able to smash LMB in my eyes. Any “nerf” of the temp health would last in “How dare you FS”. It needs a big rework, just number - handling would make it “broken” (like it already is) or just useless. + you can´t balance it overall (tanks, supports, hardcore - dd´s)