It’s not binary. This is what credibility and reputation are for.
I will not buy cosmetics untill it’s maybe extremely cheap. Reason - i don’t like Fatshark antiplayer approach. I bought some cosmetics in V2 after it became good and more or less stable game.
But with DT they dropped quality on release again and maybe even harder than with V2. And it’s their 3rd game and 3rd Tide game for me.
The whole game was built upon the player retention mechanics - rng craft, destiny 2 alike hub, timer in the armory, how missionboard works. Things like aquillas pack for xbox players only, and just poor technical quality overall like reappearing sound bugs.
Finaly the biggest problem - crafting and itemization was fixed 2 years later. Should’ve been fixed in 6 monthes or not be a problem from the start, but atleast they fixed it and now we can put some good faith in them.
But the thing is cosmetics will not become any good, cause it’s not the purpose.
Look at V2 PvP was released recently, skaven globadier has a premium skin that changes not only how globadier looks but also globe he throws.
Is there any zealot skin that changes how relic looks or throwing knives? No wonder if they will sell premium Friendly Rock skin for 20$, lol.
Look at some of V2 premium cosmetics, art design is on another level - moving parts, glowing effects, attention to details. Sure some are simplistic and average, but price is different aswell.
The whole thing they drop trailers for V2 cosmetics, but not for DT.
People buy pricy PoE cosmetics cause the ammount of free content GGG drops would cost more if it was paid.