K, I'm gonna say it

This problem has two fundamental issues

  1. Skill tree is packed tight. Since you need to have all options to be viable and so it’s easy to grab the strongest options and play all rounder build, wich every build in game is.

If you take a game with 100+ lvls like Poe/PoE2, there are stats nodes leading to clusters, wich forces you to spread your tree wide if you want (and you want) to grab juicy stuff.

Neither DT has a proper synergy between items and tree, there some examples, but it’s not like you’re stacking fire damage + las weapons talents to play with infantry las.

  1. There are no class locks.

It’s balanced so everyone could play with anything and kill everything. Because there is no restrictions, not even a weapon weight system so you couldn’t take 2 strongest anti armor options. I suppose weapon mobility should penalize a player, but it doesn’t work rly.

So I don’t expect them to go for a pre talent tree state.

And since it’s impossible the combat scenarios should rely on creating troublesome situations for different playstyles instead of classes, cause classes don’t exist anymore.

I (and other people) were giving examples dogs should see through stealth.

If there is such strong toughness refilling abilities like VOC, then there should be some enemy witch that casts toughness refill deny area/golden toughness deny. Just don’t press VOC on the cursed ground, skill issue, gg. Shotgunners shouldn’t swap to melee but zone out melee rushers, enemy psyker casts rot flies clouds at gunners/elites/both that reduce range damage they take, except fire maybe, etc.

In such cases you don’t need to make the game tactical and slow, in fact it can be reverse, because more thinking per second would be involved. Possibilities don’t exist without restrictions.

Yes, I believe that a team should be punished for a bad composition because it’s a COOP GAME. The question is how big the punishment should be.

And yes, your choice should matter and have consequences, either way why bother about what to use be it knife or thunder hammer. Should be a knife completely unable to kill crushers? Not rly, but should be least efficient, but then it should be handy against other enemy types, but they should be threatening aswell. A blob of bruisers should be a treat in melee. A swarm of groaners should be able to cheap your hp if you’re on a slower playstyle side.

It will also increase the replayability factor cause you learned how to play melee browler doesn’t mean you know how to play backline range. You need some mentality shift currently when you switch classes, but it’s not like there is whole new game is awaiting you.

Yeah, there’s dozens and dozens of topics and posts like this. None are even acknowledged by FS.

There’s even more posts like this, but that’s because people got tired of repeating the previously detailed posts.

FS is already working hard towards having 1k players. They’ll get there.

It’s not racism to say there are cultural differences. Every Chinese player will tell you cheating in games is rampant and they have a very different mentally towards how games are played.

Not really. We’re saying lower difficulties should be in place for casuals and highest difficulties should cater to the die-hards.

Having different difficulties and making them meaningful is not gatekeeping. You just want a participation trophy and it has to be on Auric and Havoc for some reason.

Do players complain when they can’t beat the hardest difficulties in God of War or Doom? No. They just lower the difficulty. I don’t understand why Darktide players expect this to be different.

In Darktide, this works poorly. A basic Auric mission with strong teammates is easier than a High Intensity Heresy mission with weak teammates

Here’s my post from today about how quickplay throws you into missions of fundamentally different difficulty:

yes, lowering the difficulty works poorly when every joe thinks he’s entitled to having all badges and bling, and if he can’t, then perhaps he’ll find some kind souls who will carry him through his chosen difficulty, kicking and screaming.

So what is a player supposed to do? Play on a difficulty that can be cleared solo (optionally while also carrying three passengers) and never venture beyond that difficulty?

clearing solo and clearing with a competent team are very different things.
a run with a team where everyone is competent looks often easier than it is, because that team eliminates threats right when they appear. while bad teammates… at least they draw some aggro so you don’t have to handle everything.

generally, i think that players should be comfortable with their current difficulty before attempting something higher. there are players in aurics who are clearly not familiar with basics, like threat prioritization, pushing, even the layout of maps. i would not try a difficulty i’m not ready for and make a fool of myself.

But it’s easy to end up looking like a fool even on a difficulty one is used to: teammates weaker than usual, the mission or its modifiers harder than usual — easy wipe

Literally just play the difficulty you’re most comfortable with.

Why would people force themselves to play on a harder difficulty if it frustrates them? I’ll never know. It’s a choice not progression. I’ve played the game since day one and I hardly ever touch high Havoc because it’s not my taste.

Also, pub RNG is just the nature of coop games. If you don’t want that then bring friends, or ask FS to give you competent bots but good luck waiting for that.

Because they want to destroy the game for others…
This is like the persons who vote for a political figure that will hurt the other side. They will be hurt also, however, they feel satisfied if the other side is hurt more.

There are no real difficulty levels in the game. They’re too blurred and overlap too much. By pressing the same quickplay button and selecting the same difficulty, one can end up in situations where the skill required to succeed differs by a factor of ten. In one game everything goes smoothly, and in the very next one all the teammates drop like flies almost simultaneously

There are definitely difficulty levels in the game. You don’t have to choose quickplay - and in all honesty, I have never understood why ANYONE would choose quickplay. I am getting close to 2000 hours and in that time I have hit quickplay maybe 5 times, 4 of which were by accident. Extra materials? You’ll get plenty of materials if you actually enjoy the game - quickplay isn’t going to make or break anything.

I spent 20+ hours progressing through each difficulty. That INCLUDES low intensity/hi intensity and Hi shock. Struggle with Damnation? Move to Heresy. Struggle with Heresy? Stay in Malice until you’re comfortable. Once you’re comfortable in damnation, then you can try low intensity. Get comfy? Hi intensity. Once you are comfortable with hi intensity, you can try shock troop gauntlet. Once you are comfortable with shock troop, you can try HI shock troop gauntlet.

This is LITERAL common sense yet we have people asking for a better tutorial and they say the difficulty levels are all over the place? No. This game isn’t meant to hold your hand - it’s an experience that no other game will provide and people only dampen their own experience by not putting in time and effort to actually be a better teammate/player.

The phrase “when you’re comfortable you can try” is lost on 90% of the player base as they think level 30 = access to the hardest tiers of content while doing absolutely nothing other than dying and reviving.

Edit: I will say, the difficulty has seen a huge spike since when I first “learned” the game and progressed through the difficulties. They will throw a lot more armor at you now even on low difficulties which is why it is very important to choose the correct MODIFIERS. If you don’t want anything crazy, stick with a regular mission with no modifiers. If you want a little more struggle, start doing missions with modifiers.

Of course, I don’t have 2,000 hours in the game—only about 580—but I’m still not one of those people who think that reaching level 30 alone is a good reason to try the highest difficulty levels.

However, I looked at the statistics of my recent matches and noticed the following:

  • Malice: 15 successful missions out of 15 (and whether there were Ogryns or not didn’t matter).
    So am I good enough to try higher difficulties?

Now Heresy:

  • Regular Heresy (no Ogryn event): 13 successes out of 13

  • Heresy with Ogryns: 2 successes, 7 failures

Now Damnation:

  • Regular Damnation: 6 successes out of 6

  • Damnation with Ogryns: 2 successes, 3 failures

Now Auric:

  • Regular Auric: 3 successes, 2 failures

  • Auric with Ogryns: 0 successes, 2 failures

So what it looks like is that Malice, regular Heresy, and regular Damnation are statistically the same difficulty level for me (100% success rate). But Heresy with Ogryns is already a different level entirely.

Which means that in Darktide, for a player who isn’t particularly strong, it’s impossible to simply lower the difficulty and relax. Malice becomes too easy, but on Heresy it’s easy to get crushed if RNG throws a mission with Ogryns

Without Ogryns the situation does become easier, of course. But even without them, High Intensity is a completely different level of difficulty compared to normal missions (even compared to Shock Troop).

I remember noticing sometime late last year that I was successfully completing regular Damnation missions about three out of four times, but High Intensity Damnation only about once out of four—with the exact same build.

I feel that it’s too easy for people fresh-off of 30 to just join Auric or even Maelstrom’s thinking in their mind that they’re ready for it, lol. They literally have no experience at all to even keep up with more experienced players. I say this because the vast majority of games with people around 30 to level 50ish (maybe even a touch beyond that). You have to either carry them & pick them up literally dozens of times or they rage-quit, reguardless. It’s pretty frustrating sometimes. I honestly don’t think the progression system goes far enough in my eyes. It’s not enough time to really get basic skills down in this game. If it were up to me, I’d have it based off of true level or something where they can only get granted access if they’re a certain level, let’s say maybe about level 100 for example to enter Auric. I would be slightly stricter on it, personally.

Like, this one game in a Maelstrom, this guy was a level 34 & kept going down, so I was with two other guys in my pre-made at the time & once he went down, we never rescued him because he was too much of a burden. He got super pissed at us in the chat, but we told him you need a bit more practice first before coming into these higher difficulties. We weren’t even trying to be dk’s about it. That’s just an example of why I think the progression system is too lenient & easy just to get into harder difficulties. So, yeah, basically, I don’t think people that are noobs should just be able to jump into harder content without any struggle of really earning it.

I have had days where I fail 3-4 missions in a row from random stuff - boss knocking me off an edge, being thrown into a demon, barrel knocking me off an edge, insane spawns, etc. Some days you literally just aren’t meant to win, that’s how it is. It’s rng, luck, whatever you want to call it. Other days I will win practically every game, other days it’s a massive struggle. Other days I actually get carried because of how utterly OP the new classes can be in the correct hands.

I came to the conclusion, I can learn something from every experience. Whether its a death caused by a trapper through a huge crowd or a barrel knocking me off an edge - there’s almost ALWAYS something to learn and at the end of the day, this is literally war. Random deaths are going to happen - you saw Saving Private Ryan? Imagine we are the people going onto the beaches of Normandy except this is set in 40k universe. It’s actually pretty realistic for only the VETERANS to be able to properly survive on this hellhole and even then, vets can die just as easy as the newbies depending on circumstances.

Because gaming is hobby and generally unserious thing (besides best attempts of certain people to turn it into sports too), and sports is a massive industry with tremendous government involvement with budget of billions and global politics at stakes. That’s, literally, the only reason why. Also, it’s not true, and probably in every sport you’ll see that majority of people in the world that are doing it use some very budget equipment not suitable for any kind of sport competitions, or something that is specifically developed for enthusiasts. Like, in the sport I’m familiar with well enough - cycling - guess what kind of bikes 99.99% of people in the world use lol? Yea, right, the dirty cheap city bikes, the ugly heavy Chinese knockoffs of decades old mountain bikes, and some simple models of more “sportish” designs which are still heavily adapted to be used by somebody who has neither stamina, nor muscles, nor skills of a professional athlete.

Percentage of people who are doing any kind of serious sports as a career is laughably tiny, comparing to people who just do it as a hobby. It’s even less when it comes to games which are historically never were designed or intended for any kind of serious competition or proving something to somebody. 99.99% of games ever existed were made for people to just have fun. That world that is “built around sportsmen” exist mostly in your head, mate. You saw it on TV, but TV isn’t the real life.

That’s because currently 90% of the Elites and Specialists suck at the individual level, and are really only a threat when spammed heavily or given ridiculous modifiers like Gunners into Reapers or Encroaching Garden etc. It’s not that the modifier like Encroaching is bad, it’s an interesting idea but could be better implemented.

Hopefully that’s going to change soon with this new update, I’m eager to see what it brings.

yeah, those esport pros are awfully paid for their performance :man_facepalming:

not

while it’ll be futile to explain why you miss the point by a mile, it’s not about the faceless masses that use inferior crap to mask their lack of devotion to a sport or abilities like you mentioned with

uhu, they use cheap :poop: cause they’re content in their place and never aspire for higher, sheeple in the literal sense.

but guess what bike the tour de france contenders use and by whom they’re designed.

the fact common-joe from the woods doesn’t know how to utilize the device isn’t taking from the fact that if you want to create something of quality you hire people with expertise in the field and not said wood-dweller that rides his bike to the next distillery.

I’ll never understand the logic “oh others are slacking as well, so it’s the “norm” and ok to do the minimum as well, 99% of cheap bike riders can’t be wrong”

thing is I don’t measure his stroll to work, I measure him against lance armstrong when he enters the realm of competitive bike riding.

yet in this here example he enters the realm of said athletes and should be measured as such.

as soon as other people aka multiplayer is involved it aint a relaxed ride through the woods its a competition.

you might not like the fact your teammates are holding you accountable if falling short on the performance level, but by joining a team your obligated to deliver your “best” not slack around and hit the pedal every 2 miles while the others drag you along.

you play single player games, it’s completely up to you how far you wanna push yourself, once others are involved it’s not, simple as that.

and seeing the “tide” of carries and “participators”

this games balance could truly use a push in terms of balance to demand more of each individually rather than handing out talents and weapons that compensate.

once one is forced to perfect the basic, he’s a valuable asset in higher difficulties.

hitting the ult button once or twice at the right moment he’s not

as soon as other people aka multiplayer is involved it aint a relaxed ride through the woods its a competition

I think you picked wrong on two counts. First it’s a game with only PvE, secondly it’s a game intentionally designed around cooperation.

I think most people aren’t holding you accountable for that much, you’re just imagining some sort of presence, of your own making, criticizing your every step and you internalized that so much that you think it’s how the world works or how most other people work.

You picked the wrong game.

so far the slackers that got carried havent complained.

maybe you got the wrong attitude towards performance :man_shrugging:

so thats an excuse now for making yourself a burden for others?

cooperation means contributing, not receiving charity.

no one can hold me accountable to such a high standard as I hold myself to it.

like i wrote in the other thread “if not be your best, why be at all?”

there’s dozens and dozens of topics and posts like this

When I make the point that if you are going to talk about balance you should indicate what you intend to balance for, and your response is to make a broad sweeping gesture at the forums, then you (a) you have chosen to try to engage with me but ignore what I’ve said and (b) are providing absolutely no additional information regarding what you think Darktide should look like on a fundamental level. Which is certainly a choice.

It’s not racism to say there are cultural differences.

It is rather odd how eagerly some people have lined up to indignantly reject accusations of racism which, in fact, I have not made. I agree it isn’t racism to say people can have cultural differences – but (a) that isn’t what was said and (b) implying that cultural traditions within a population of ca. 1.4 billion people are sufficiently homogenous to draw incredibly strong and broad conclusions strikes me as about as accurate as suggesting that that people from Germany and Spain (or California and Alabama if you are USian) are basically psychosocially identical. In short, to put this as kindly as possible, it does rather seem to be the conclusion of a somewhat incurious and parochial mind.

Not really. We’re saying lower difficulties should be in place for casuals and highest difficulties should cater to the die-hards.

Er, no, literally people were talking about how average should be considered an insult and that you should strive to become the best of the best otherwise you are wasting time. While misrepresenting what has been said once could be a mistake, twice is beginning to look like deliberate disingenuousness. But in a fit of absurd generosity, I’ll play along and pretend that actually there was a thoughtful and well-intentioned discussion regarding how to balance to ensure a fair experience for all players – you still haven’t said anything about what that should look like (if, as seems to be the case, you believe that Heresy and above should be for the ‘die-hards’ only, it might be worth considering how many people that actually is and the subsequent effect on spreading that population out – you know, if you were to actually give this any thought at all).

You just want a participation trophy and it has to be on Auric and Havoc for some reason.

And now we see not just an incurious mind, but an extremely presumptuous one as well (particularly given the points I’ve made have had nothing to do with how I think the game should be balanced). Just for the record, as someone who has been playing Darktide from the pre-order Beta onwards, I have achieved a level of proficiency I am quite comfortable with - and I have pretty much zero interest in Havoc, as it strikes me as a mode which incentivises metabuilding (which I have little interest in, preferring to…you know…play the game for fun – a shocking approach I know!) and the sort of player mentality which I have little interest in encountering in what is, at least nominally, supposed to be a co-operative game.

However, to again be incredibly generous and try to treat this sort of deeply ignorant inane dribbling as if there is any value to it, I would strongly recommend you think about the issues in Havoc which many “die-hards” who play there experience (such as the strong meta-drive) and what would happen if you rebalance to push those difficulties down to Heresy (that is to say, the strong risk of exacerbating the very weapon and class imbalances already prevalent). Or, to repeat my point for what feels like the 1000th time, if you plan to do anything other than tinker around the edges, you have to actually consider the game mechanics at a meta-level (and no, just waving in the direction of the forums and saying “other people done it” doesn’t count).

They just lower the difficulty. I don’t understand why Darktide players expect this to be different.

I suppose I could waste my time explaining to you the issues with Darktide’s difficulty modes (such as the lack of granularity, the spikes cause by certain mutators, and that the difficulty a player experiences is a function of many variables only some of which may be controlled for, to name but a few) which make “play to your difficulty” a somewhat useless thought-terminating cliché (and the comparisons to single player games particularly poorly considered). But as I’ve already put far more effort into this reply than you did into yours (and nothing in your post suggests you actually have either the interest or ability to engage with such discussions) I will merely restate my belief that there is value into giving the topic greater consideration from a broader game design perspective should you ever feel like making a useful contribution to the conversations. Or don’t – it is your choice, after all.