This problem has two fundamental issues
- Skill tree is packed tight. Since you need to have all options to be viable and so it’s easy to grab the strongest options and play all rounder build, wich every build in game is.
If you take a game with 100+ lvls like Poe/PoE2, there are stats nodes leading to clusters, wich forces you to spread your tree wide if you want (and you want) to grab juicy stuff.
Neither DT has a proper synergy between items and tree, there some examples, but it’s not like you’re stacking fire damage + las weapons talents to play with infantry las.
- There are no class locks.
It’s balanced so everyone could play with anything and kill everything. Because there is no restrictions, not even a weapon weight system so you couldn’t take 2 strongest anti armor options. I suppose weapon mobility should penalize a player, but it doesn’t work rly.
So I don’t expect them to go for a pre talent tree state.
And since it’s impossible the combat scenarios should rely on creating troublesome situations for different playstyles instead of classes, cause classes don’t exist anymore.
I (and other people) were giving examples dogs should see through stealth.
If there is such strong toughness refilling abilities like VOC, then there should be some enemy witch that casts toughness refill deny area/golden toughness deny. Just don’t press VOC on the cursed ground, skill issue, gg. Shotgunners shouldn’t swap to melee but zone out melee rushers, enemy psyker casts rot flies clouds at gunners/elites/both that reduce range damage they take, except fire maybe, etc.
In such cases you don’t need to make the game tactical and slow, in fact it can be reverse, because more thinking per second would be involved. Possibilities don’t exist without restrictions.
Yes, I believe that a team should be punished for a bad composition because it’s a COOP GAME. The question is how big the punishment should be.
And yes, your choice should matter and have consequences, either way why bother about what to use be it knife or thunder hammer. Should be a knife completely unable to kill crushers? Not rly, but should be least efficient, but then it should be handy against other enemy types, but they should be threatening aswell. A blob of bruisers should be a treat in melee. A swarm of groaners should be able to cheap your hp if you’re on a slower playstyle side.
It will also increase the replayability factor cause you learned how to play melee browler doesn’t mean you know how to play backline range. You need some mentality shift currently when you switch classes, but it’s not like there is whole new game is awaiting you.