Guys, let's be honest here: How accurate is this?

Found this gem on twitter got me thinking :thinking:

24 Likes

Very, one could also be done about Genestealer cults.

8 Likes

Not entirely accurate. The main problem we have is that the hive scum is very simply lame af. Really, what is special and exciting about a simple hive ganger? Even their weapons are lame. A crowbar, a bonesaw, and a dinky little knife? We can find those weapons in other games just fine, we wanted something more specific to 40k. Also, the backlash is due to how awesome arbitrator was so the expectation was that the class would be equal to or higher than arbitrator in cool factor/power level. A hive ganger really isn’t anything special, you can find a normal “scum” archetype anywhere, it’s just not that insipired. It’s boring and lame. So I doubt there would be as much backlash if they released hive ganger, then arbitrator since the power levels would be escalatory instead of a flat downgrade

2 Likes

should be f2p

5 Likes

Found one

4 Likes

I understand you get in with all the cool play testers so you have to defend this hive scum decision but you could at least address the arguments I brought forth

2 Likes

the malding/review bombing that the children that only care about flashing lights in their theme park is kinda funny sorry.

2 Likes

Notice how they didnt review bomb with arbitrator? Because arbitrator is cool, hive scum is boring and lame. Do you understand

7 Likes

If you read forum, you will see it’s very accurate and funny.

1 Like

I don’t think the hive scum is interesting thematically or aesthetically… but the mechanics from the dev blog seem unique enough. At the end of the day, it’s a first person game where I barely see my character so if it plays well I’ll have fun personally.

I don’t think they deserve to get review bombed for it but… yeah, I think it was obvious to see people weren’t going to be happy about this one in terms of lore/coolness.

6 Likes

be careful, common sense is not welcome round ‘ere.

2 Likes

So we’re at the “Players expected too much” part. Reminds me of Cyberpunk 2077 when it released.

FS didn’t say we got tech priest, and I expected Ganger from the get go, because this is FS and they will always go for the lowest hanging fruit.

But it’s still disapointing. Because it’s lame and a mash up of existing classes.

6 Likes

There was some speculation about techpriest for Arbites but it was drowned out by RATLINGS NOW and the people who (correctly) guessed Arbitrator/Enforcer due to the hound.

But honestly people are more salty it’s a relatively boring class with a boring paint-by-numbers trailer. The class breakdown basically going ‘so y’know how there’s vet right-hand tree and zealot right-hand tree, what if both of those were in one class’ instead of something more out-there also sparked rage.

People like it when there’s something new and interesting, and Hive Scum are just Reject Premium.

4 Likes

You are right, listening to the people you want money from about what they are willing to give you money for is such a stupid idea. Better make something completely irrelevant and see if it sticks with your customer base. If not, just cancel the whole project and move on to repeat past mistakes. Genius!

And I don’t even care for an Ad Mech class, I just think it would be more interesting.
I’m more in line with a Commissar class.

4 Likes

There’s like nothing engage with here. Most of your recent posts are complaining that the women in the game aren’t hot enough and the others are just crying that one class out of 6 doesn’t click with you. I can only imagine what the many posts you have that were flagged were saying that somehow make those posts look mundane. Go pound sand.

3 Likes

I legitimately think the idea of a new class hard carried arbites release. Now that people are more used to it they’re just going “wow this class is just a mishmash of the others” but that was also arbites, people just didn’t complain until they got the class and went “wow, lonewolf is just vet but better” or “they got psyker dodge talents with zealot and ogryn damage nodes”.

Were people really not expecting class homogeny? There’s only like 2 ability types they can take from vermintide at this point, and that’s ults that deal an immediate set of damage then go on cooldown (grail knight, waystalker, bountyhunter), and an ult that pulls out a third weapon that recharges overtime (engineer). Keystones function almost exactly the same between characters and are either passive stacks of bonus stats gained by killing elite/specials/horde (piety, heavy hitter, execution order, DD), or activated upon reaching a conditional (weapons specialist, martyrdom, lucky bullet, whatever 3rd arbites keystone is).

This just seems like the most obvious thing to me. Did anyone really expect 3 completely unique above and beyond designed abilities, blitz, and auras and keystones? This exact problem would’ve been prevalent in admech as well.

5 Likes

I really don’t understand people who go on Steam and write a negative review of the game after a 1000+ hours, because “oh no, the new class isn’t x” or “where is my solo mode, in the coop game?"

6 Likes

Wtf is this comparison to cyberpunk? Fatshark promised new class, not even specific class while cd project red promised so much more than what we got, especially on release, cdpr created players expectations.

There was no promise that it will be x class, instead people speculated and started to believe that their speculation will be correct one.

2 Likes

I speculated that it was ganger from the start because it’s lowest effort and I was right.

1 Like

People use Steam reviews as a cudgel when the only thing a company listens to is those reviews.

Consistent complaints about an issue like cosmetics or solo mode across the forums and reddit, but no review tanking? Utter silence.

Accidentally left in potential patch notes for ds and plasma and people got salty enough to tank the reviews? Immediate apology moving at the speed of sound.

That’s why my review remains negative until the shop stops being garbage, and I constantly push people who have problems with the game to leave negative reviews. It’s the only thing that gets Fatshark to say and do stuff.

4 Likes