,,Event" Fatshark are you serious?

I do think it is important to decide how these events are going to be utilized in terms of narrative.

Are they supposed to propel/add to the current “story”? If so, then there needs to be enough interactive elements like one of the twins showing up mid game for people to get excited about, but not something that requires all that effort and then we see it happen once (or twice in this case) and then never again. (Maybe something mid mission happens at random that opens a side path? A valkyrie crashes and roadblocks the main path? Scripted fight scenes where heretics are finishing off loyalists as we arrive in the elevator transition? With voice acting!!!)

One solution that would let you re-use events while keeping them tied to the story would be (and I’m just spitballing here) chalking it up to warp shenanigans. Yadda yadda echoes of the warp blah blah Twins invading the map is back this week except this time you slapped a spectral, transparent green effect on them.

This would at least let you rotate lesser interactive events in between newer or grander ones.

But if the events are going to be mostly “non-canon” affairs then just start going crazy with modifiers since it doesn’t have to make sense to rotate back in later. Between the chaos wastes and old deed system there’s tons of inspiration to grab from there.

If you want these events to just be fun and video gamey then the sky is the limit. 4x mob density but it’s all poxwalkers and specials, players get double toughness and/or hp, roaming Demonhosts that can be skirted around, but you still have to be wary of, enemy density starting off laughably small but getting progressively worse the longer the mission takes, artificial gravity is turned off for some reason, etc.

Alternatively if that all is too much effort, then rename these “Play X matches” and “Do X thing” affairs to something like Flash Objectives or whatever. Because to most players, that’s all they are. Just another daily/weekly, except this time you can miss out. But also missing out doesn’t matter because you aren’t getting anything you wouldn’t already get by just playing normally.

Your regulars never stopped playing and it’s likely you are drawing back a negligible number of casuals in between their other games. (I assume, I don’t have the numbers to verify this)

This exactly. The Karnaks teasing themselves in the leadup to the Offensive was undoubtedly the most fun part of the whole thing. Hearing that ominous laughter in the distance and then suddenly some raid boss shows up to kick your teeth in while you’re already struggling was a LOT of fun and shook things up.

I was really excited for this event, and then I got whiplash when it was “this guy again”. It definitely gives off the vibe of a rushed asset flip.

I’m always in favour of alternate path branches.

Oh no! a g-g-ghost!

how about something that ISN’T the rinda or rodin and actually intoduces a new enemy. a cosmetic reward for people who clear the event, much MUCH less fake outs like this one. those are good places to start.

The chaos gods mutating her and saving her, whilst influencing her to change sides (still an enemy but working for Nurgle not Wulfer) would have been a fabulous take for this event. I agree 100%.

Agree, its a free event with new dialogue, I haven’t played it yet but still like the drop. Its better than nothing…Not sure what players expectations are for free content, which leads me to point at FS for not setting expectations. Players dissapointed are right in the sense they can only assume based on their own expectations of content.

New modifiers , I think the boss could have been introduced with a re-skin, or given us an understanding to how she survived her “death”. Because FS decided to call it an event there should be a “gimmick” or new mechanic added to the missions. Maybe re-titling the event to something to set up expectations. All in all I think FS just needs to communicate on expectations for content.

Events should come with a cosmetic reward, trinket, or something to show you paticipated, even if its just a border or title.


That explains why I have not seen Rinda all day; shame, but I will not go down from Auric Maelstrom and grief lower difficulty levels.

This is definitely something that Fatshark need to consider when planning future events, @FatsharkStrawHat.

The idea of having one of the Karnak twins appear in a mission as as random boss is not bad in itself, the game needs enemy and boss variety.

Not just recycled “this time there’s EVEN MORE DOGS” crap.

New events that are just re-uses of the same stuff in different combinations just isn’t interesting. At the very least you could give enemies more weapon varieties. Crushers with huge 2hand axes and swords? Maulers with power mauls? Reapers with plasma cannons or rocket launchers? Bombers that throw concussion grenades instead of molotovs? The pox bomber was a step in the right direction. I want to see more.

More different monstrosities, with more different weapons and abilities. A different kind of plague ogryn, perhaps with tentacles? More teeth and extra mouthes?

You could do a lot more with the twins than you’re doing currently. Reskins, alter their abilities, maybe some different attacks. Is Rinda a psyker? It’s not entirely clear. If she is, emphasize it. Make her do bio-lightning, have psychich phenomena appear around her when she uses her powers: frost on the floor, a few snow flakes, foggy breath in the air, subtle sparks of eldritch warp lightning runs across the floor for a second, players hear demonic whispers, etc. etc.

Get creative.

You could even make it so if players manage to bait her into a specific attack-pattern, she pushes her psychic powers too far(stagger her 3 times in a row quickly, say) she would be an unsanctioned psyker of course and cause something horrible, like have her literally scream and then burst apart in pink and purple warpflame (like players do who keep casting at 100% peril) and then some small daemons appear like nurglings(or the plaguebeast, it’s a daemon) in an explosion of vomit or whatever. Or have her grow a massive tentacle that changes her behavior. This universe has so much potential and you’re barely tapping any of it.

Enemy psyker specials. They can be minibosses ala monstrosities and the karnak twins (with a broader range of psychic powers), and they can be specials (like a 1trick pony that casts fire balls or bio-lightning and dies easy).

DOGS! Where do they come from? Dogs are born by other dogs. There could be an event centered around a “den mother/pack leader” massive boss-dog that spawns near the end of a mission that has the hunting grounds modifier. Scale up and modify the dog, give it unique attackpatterns. Tentacles? More teeth? More psychic BS and perils of the warp? Yes!

Possessed machines? Hereteks? The Dark mechanicum is essentially completely untapped in this game. Chaos murder servitors? Chaos servo skulls? Chaos cherubs with sickly buboes that scream and cry in a totally creepy way? Yes!

Daemon weapons? A miniboss drops a daemonweapon which disappears end of mission, that can be picked up by a single player. So it only works for that one mission. Like the “lights out” mission in VT2 one guy could carry the torch.
A possessed bolter, flamer, inferno pistol, or plasma gun? A unique and powerful tainted force or daemon weapon? Maybe one guy needs to carry it because it makes the last bossfight easier if you do, but you slowly gain corruption(say).

This universe has ENDLESS potential.

Just did this event and thought the boss would spawn more than once, oh how I was wrong. It is just a repeat of their last event except they changed the name and stuck a lights out tag on it. The literal definition of bare minimum effort. I would rather have them do nothing at all and focus on good content than do this BS. At least if they do nothing at all we don’t see them dedicating resources to absolute trash.

I like the direction compared to the “kill 6 billion rats” that vermintide 2 had because you can see the personal progress, its also nice to get ingame currency as a reward as you play through the tiers.

I dont like that ALL you get is currency. We need better rewards to entice us.
Im talkin cosmetics, premium currency, titles, score screen stances etc.
You already did this for christmas in V2 and I loved it, an actual chance to get premium cosmetics and red dust!

My expectations were low, I just expected Darkness + a karnak twin and even then it fell below that expectation. The event’s not even playable on auric missions.

Ahh. Still on holiday. Looks like I’m not missing much event stuff.

But in the mean time, here are two cute otters. I’ve some great pictures of wolves, but sadly behind chicken wire :cry:

Yeah I mean what possible reason could there be to put some effort into their free content?

Looks at No Man’s Sky

Ohhhhh, yeah, maybe they should?

You’re not wrong. I mean No Man Sky took what 7 years to get to this point?

I would point to Creative Assembly and Total War, specifically their dev diary they released today with detailed expectations on free and paid content.

FS hasn’t found middle ground on player expectations or set any expectations besides most things they announce will be delayed.

Baby oh baby I can’t wait for more plasteel to add to my big pile of plasteel

Vermintide 2 released in a complete state if you consider content (maps) and systems (itemization, skills, penances/Okri’s challenges ) so it may be hard to compare the two (see last paragraph), but here goes!

Vt2 had recurring events such as Skulls and Mondstille that didn’t change much at all. The Skulls event was a temporary re-model of the keep and mostly just login and play some regular content for a new frame and Mondstille had a frame(?) but also changed the lighting on the map(s). At some point there was a winter(?) event where a few alterations were made to the map urging players to light bonfires for some reason I can’t remember. Reward was also a frame or two and maybe something else.

On the one year anniversary A quiet drink was released, made available temporarily, and acted as pretty much a saving grace for the company due to months and months of connection issues and back-end errors (sound familiar?).

I’m not saying that these examples (seasonal events) are the go-to formula to get people engaged but they served a purpose. They are a cool first time thing and they tend to keep at least the core player base involved enough to engage. Deep Rock Galactic is running similar, recurring, events with a temporary remodel of the hub and a few cosmetic items themed after the event. DRG also gives you a chance to access previous years cosmetics during the yearly events.

The main issue with this event is that it’s presenting itself as something new while being a entirely re-used assets that doesn’t bring anything new content or gameplay-wise. At the same time a large part of the playerbase doesn’t even care about completing “event” maps for penances progression or gaining materials. If you lack the time or will to create an event that shakes things up or introduces a way to see the game with new eyes, I think you may as well skip the event altogether.

From what little you said about the event it sounded more in line with when the Demonhosts dropped in mid-December. Having the first Demonhost-encounter while playing a lights out/power mal. mission was pretty cool.


No matter what is done with the suggestions you receive, I don’t think the issue, currently, is the creativity or will from those working on the game but rather the backlog of issues and unfinished parts of the game that are still being worked on. The itemization re-work, the connection issues, the malfunctioning chat and the lack of QoL features speak volumes.

If they wanted that, they could simply have made a kill order, where we kill ever increasing numbers of Horde, Special and Elites…

Dunno what they thought they were doing when they decided to make an event centered around the least liked game mode, in a low affort way.

Heck, when i heard about how lame the event supposedly was i was like “oh okay, so Terror in the Dark, they took the Chaos Spawn and amped it up with a Nurgles Blessing or something”…

And honestly, i wish i could say it was that. But just reusing Rinda… where is the Terror part? The Twins are about the least frightening boss in this game. I am more worried about the Chaos Ogrin, because he can boot you over the side of the map.

Also, i forgot to pay attention, i hope Rinda at least counts for Monstrosities Contracts.. Because if she still doesn’t count, like last time, then man, i much rather have them send me a random Monstrosity.

Well… how about not lights out… at least until you give every class a chance to have a Flashlight and not just the tiny glowstick that supposedly is a light source… seriously, a Zippo casts more light than these glowsticks.

Oh and maybe not the Twins? I was excited for the idea of this being some monstrosity… or something. I thought you guys would do something. Like you have a new monstrosity and it ambushes you 2-3 times… and then you track it down to its lair and we kill it in the lair as a new end event or something.

Just a simple “oh let’s make them all play the most sucking modifier, and throw the most boring boss at them”… and you didn’t even give them a new look or anything.

How about the Terror in the Dark would have been a Nightlord Chaos Space Marine?

Also, can we maybe not make it grindy? You spend so much time working on the penances… why didn’t you use the Penances?

Like why couldn’t you go in and change one of the missions slightly different?

Pick one you like, that you can really do a horror vibe with. Some minor sound stings to put you on edge… and then some new interactables. For example, why not use Hab Dryko… use one of the NPC Soldiers, put him into one of the cells where the Martyr Skull is. Have people need to go to the cell to free the soldier. Have the Soldier, moan and whatnot. And when you press the button for the Cell it triggers a big horde and whatnot.

Then Hire the Swagger Guy to do the voice lines, and have him tell us to clear the horde and close the Airlock up top, so he can send in a rescue team for the Prisoner. Which then traps us inside the complex again. Maybe give it an “on the fritz” effect when it closes behind the operatives.

Then we go up through to the airlock and instead of running around, doing the investigation, we need to collect some books for Swagger or turn some nobs or some valves. Then we go up, through the next Airlock, and we have some hordes send our way. Maybe some weakened Demonhost… spawns and attacks the players. Slow their attacks a bit down, so people can dodge and parry them a little easier and have people deal with this special Demonhost. Add voice stingers for the Demonhost, as she laments and cries… but there is no Demonhost. Or maybe have a demonhost be present in the distance and if you get close or would trigger her she “dissolves” into black mist. Or she portals away.

Then have a first fight against the Demonhost after the 2nd Airlock, if she kills someone or is “defeated” she portals away.

And then you encounter her again, in the end room. Remove the central tree… leave the demon goop, maybe put some work detail corpses there and some shovels and whatnot, so it looks like some poor souls had been send down here to clean our mess after we defused the situation… have Swagger comment on it, so people realize that is what it is supposed to be… and then have a Demonhost boss spawn in. Use the Demonhost skin, give her the regular Assassination Boss move set, and a new particle effect shield to make it look like she has a psychic force field.

I know it would be a little work and the Swagger guy would probably need to be paid for an afternoon to speak 5-10 new voice lines…

And then as reward give a cosmetic with a proper flashlight on a backpack, for the humans and the Ogryn. Just use the Voxcaster as basis, stick an industrial light on it… and then everyone can finally get a proper flashlight for those atrocious darkness missions. Make the first one look like an Industrial thing, with rust and an industrial look. And then give 2-3 more fancy versions for doing the mission a bunch of times or depending on the difficulty.

Seriously, how much work can this be? 2-3 Days? You have supposedly 180 people working over there… there are modders that would do this on their own after work.

It is so frustrating to see just how little you guys care. But hey, sell an Ogryn Gasmask for 1400 Aquilla, why don’t you!?

Honestly I just expected more - the post makes it sound like it’s going to be new content but both the modifier and the boss are re-used. If they just want to give us more resources, sure, but they shouldn’t have made it mysterious. Just come out and say “on august 15th, you can play lights out with one of the karnak twins appearing during the mission. Play it a bunch of times and you can get plasteel.” At least you wouldn’t have given anyone false expectations.

Also its a little annoying that its not integrated into auric missions at all

In my mind, a different low effort solution to this kind of event would be a regular mission that would randomly transition into blackout, soon after which you would be attacked by a reskinned/buffed chaos spawn… at least that would be a little bit different, while still being easy to implement (i’d assume).

I posted a similar forum in “Gameplay Feedback” hoping that the thread would be better suited to get CM attention in that forum rather than general discussion. Here’s my take on the event.

This is really helpful, thank you!

Especially the additional points. I had these in my report but it really underlines it. Thanks for taking the time to write it out.