I do think it is important to decide how these events are going to be utilized in terms of narrative.
Are they supposed to propel/add to the current “story”? If so, then there needs to be enough interactive elements like one of the twins showing up mid game for people to get excited about, but not something that requires all that effort and then we see it happen once (or twice in this case) and then never again. (Maybe something mid mission happens at random that opens a side path? A valkyrie crashes and roadblocks the main path? Scripted fight scenes where heretics are finishing off loyalists as we arrive in the elevator transition? With voice acting!!!)
One solution that would let you re-use events while keeping them tied to the story would be (and I’m just spitballing here) chalking it up to warp shenanigans. Yadda yadda echoes of the warp blah blah Twins invading the map is back this week except this time you slapped a spectral, transparent green effect on them.
This would at least let you rotate lesser interactive events in between newer or grander ones.
But if the events are going to be mostly “non-canon” affairs then just start going crazy with modifiers since it doesn’t have to make sense to rotate back in later. Between the chaos wastes and old deed system there’s tons of inspiration to grab from there.
If you want these events to just be fun and video gamey then the sky is the limit. 4x mob density but it’s all poxwalkers and specials, players get double toughness and/or hp, roaming Demonhosts that can be skirted around, but you still have to be wary of, enemy density starting off laughably small but getting progressively worse the longer the mission takes, artificial gravity is turned off for some reason, etc.
Alternatively if that all is too much effort, then rename these “Play X matches” and “Do X thing” affairs to something like Flash Objectives or whatever. Because to most players, that’s all they are. Just another daily/weekly, except this time you can miss out. But also missing out doesn’t matter because you aren’t getting anything you wouldn’t already get by just playing normally.
Your regulars never stopped playing and it’s likely you are drawing back a negligible number of casuals in between their other games. (I assume, I don’t have the numbers to verify this)
