Does Fatshark respond?

Oh. You’re not aware of the nonsense.

puts on ‘knows way more than he wants to about internet idiocy’ hat

Okay, short primer:

‘Soy’ is, as you probably know, about being wimpy and weak. Why is it that? Because of a deranged right-wing conspiracy theory about soy being full of estrogen and used to ‘feminize’ men. I wish I was making this up.

sigma gigachad is just normal Redditese at this point, mostly used ironically - it kinda ties into the whole ‘alpha male’ nonsense but ‘sigma’ specifically is memed on far more so it’s not gonna make people side-eye you.

Ah those two.

For soy i know where its origin come from, but tbh i don’t think it matters, meme is just a meme, a cultural virus, especially when it comes into my native laguage - russian with some time delay and via different sources.

It’s mostly from 4chan as i know, but become popular with Patrick Bateman and Gosling memes shitposting, and some “embrace masculinity” youtube memes.

Fair. They should have announced pre-release what features were going to change based on the last status update they gave.



Of course they are not.
The right course of action would be to have someone wade through the feedback with thick skin and respond selectively, rather than reading in silence (they are reading this forum, Discord and Reddit - they have proven that time after time).

That said, you also get the occasional “stray developer” reading. When the feedback is mostly level headed, you have a much better chance of being heard and that’s all I’m really advertizing for.
Don’t think I believe this game is perfect. There is a lot of opportunities where Fatshark misses out on incredible potential.



Not necessarily. When it starts to feel like the world is against you, it becomes increasingly harder to get out of your shell (and a lot of creatives are introverts). That’s what their CM is for of course.



What personally gets me is that they already had a very successful bi-weekly update thing. It was well-received, too. I don’t understand why they dropped that.



On the other hand, what’s taught in business school these days goes contrary to that. The moment you excuse yourself, you give away power and a feeling of vindication against and over you. So most companies avoid that.
I don’t think they see themselves as having made mistakes, either. This is exactly the framing they probably want to avoid.



That’s actually not Reddit Terminology, Reddit is a space that’d be rather opposed to “based” and “Gigachad” and such memes. It originates elsewhere.

From Catfish’s statements, its summed up as the following:

  1. Lack of stuff to talk about due to (not directly stated) Fatshark’s slow development practices made people mad.
  2. Because people were mad, it was genuinely exhausting and bad to deal with moderating the comments that inevitably resulted from every Comms-Link, and (not directly stated) I think Catfish got burnt out on it as the only person doing said communication.

Then I’m clearly in the wrong end of said hellsite.

Kind of proving my point there a little. That said, I disagree with her notion that there is little to talk about.

Missed opportunity here: There is plenty of content and backend work they could have talked about. Digging through the code and the backend files, we ourselves have found plenty of interesting stuff that’s worth a short comment at least.



Now I’m really curious what subreddits you dwell in. lol

But they did an apologize, with corpo speech jpg

Summary

It realy comes down to how you choose your words and build your relationships with community. Some companies are trying to keep a distance, some act like they are gamers and bros.

I don’t think Fatshark acts like they are in a position of power. More like a cat - pissed on shoes and hide under the bad.

Oh nice thx!

I also disagree that there’s very little to talk about.

But that’s the reasoning she gave.

You left out a key part, it’s a failure to temper expectations. Something that is important to managing a community.

There are some good reasons for Devs not to individually respond to topics, but Fatshark’s communications overall fail basic Marketing (as a profession) standards.

People will be salty online. Part of communications is handling that. Being able to accept it, being able to separate the useful info from the noise, being able to roll with it and dish it out, etc. That’s what people ostensibly get paid to do. It’s not pretty, but the companies that best respond to this sort of thing do better. If you want to get money out of people, you need to make them want to spend that money, you don’t get to blame them for not giving you money.

If you showcase/promise something for a product and fail to make it happen, that’s on you. You made the value proposition and failed to deliver.

If your concept changes or develops in a different direction for your for-profit software service, and you fail to communicate that fact and people get mad about it, again, you made a value proposition and failed to deliver and that’s on you.

If people get mad at you on message boards for failing to deliver or communicate, that shouldn’t be an excuse to cease communications. People are allowed to be mad about those things as customers of a for-profit software service, negative feedback sucks but it’s important, and if you ignore that your product fails in the marketplace.

If you do something that enrages your userbase, own it and roll with it. Give up something, accept the criticism (embrace it even, become the memes), and keep talking. Otherwise it just becomes an open wound and something for people to pick on.

If your customer base is screaming a coherent message at you around a specific functionality for months (like itemization and crafting) and you steadfastly refuse to even address or talk about it, much less actually do something about it, it’s on you when your customers leave and your product sees declining usage.

If you have offer literally nothing public for future plans regarding your for-profit software service, and drop updated and patches without any news or lead-in, it’s on you when people react poorly and user counts decline.

You don’t get to use these as excuses as to why you don’t communicate if you’re interested in the continued success of your product.

This doesn’t mean Fatshark needs to respond to every post or item, it doesn’t mean they need to take everything posted as gospel, it doesn’t mean they need to cater to any particular user or group or platform, but Fatshark’s current communications and community interaction are failures, simple as, and what people choose to spend their time playing reflects that.

As is, Darktide has lost players every month since launch except for Oct 23 with Patch 13. Player numbers are down 2/3rds from that peak and are down 35% over the last 30 days alone, and over 95% from the launch peak. Other 4-person coop shooters 5/10/15 years old are showing active player numbers 5-10x higher than Darktide and holding far more steady over time and often significantly higher player counts now than at their launch (L4D2, DRG, etc).

There is clearly a problem with Darktide, and Fatshark doesn’t want to talk about it. Whether that’s because they’ve determined they milked the majority of their income at launch already and just relegated the title to Support Mode, or because they have a vision that they just don’t want feedback on, or some other reason, I don’t know, but the problem is real.

The main place they talk on is the Discord

I stopped getting Acknowledgements on some of my bug reports. I assume they are hard at work!

Amen

I can’t believe I’m saying this, but Creative Assembly is a good example of this at the moment.

They recognized that they needed people to buy WH3 DLC and Pharaoh if they wanted to stay solvent, and that the constant degradation in quality and overpricing was driving people away. So they made public apologies, refunded people the difference in price while slashing Pharoah’s prices, and generally made actual steps towards materially ‘making good’ the problems.

Fatshark has…not done that. Fatshark has done virtually everything but address the problems the community raises.

Hate the rotating shop? Well, it’s still rotating, but we’ll insult your intelligence and then slightly extend the timer for how long something remains available.

Hate the RNG? Here’s five more layers of it.

Hate how we lie? We’ll just go utterly silent.

Hate the unevenness of platform rewards? Here’s some random cosmetics nobody asked for.

Maybe that means people are buying the cosmetics?

CA changed because people voted with their wallets. Idk if people have stopped buying cosmetics, or that FS have met their goals with their pricing strategy.

Every rotation, I regularly encounter people who has the latest and the greatest from the cash shop. So, from my perspective, people are buying the skins like crazy. Right now, the Ogryn welding mask skin is worn by every other Ogryn. A few games ago, both Ogryns in the game had it. :sweat_smile:

I know what you mean. I can’t believe it either. CA didn’t want to refund people for that DLC. The comments was more “content” for keeping that price. Looks like it worked as DLC reviews just done a complete 180 praising it.

I mean for Pharoah they could of done the same thing. Keep the same price, but allow time to add features to the game.

Their follow up included a survey and among it what people may want in the next theme. So it will probably be Warhammer 40K out of the choices.

Something I mentioned was getting feedback from DT players in same manner. It is hard to get as much people to respond. But if add incentive they do so i.e. dockets for response.

An interesting goodwill gesture and so rapidly too. Reminds of when Cyberpunk in one month let anyone regardless of play time and any platform PC, Xbox, PS they would give refunds. The confidence of knowing losing money now to build trust to make more money in future as overall goal, not a small sum either I bet.

Cosmetic purchases isn’t a bad thing. It is when it becomes too much focus.

DT cosmetics have no effect on gameplay. But who knows what would happen if no one bought any cosmetics and they would have to focus on other gameplay elements to attract new players as sole revenue instead.

I think that the failure of Hyenas meant a lot of panic and approval of ‘drastic measures’ among the higher-ups there. They were thinking that things could be fine and they’d make it all back with Generic Shooter 2024…and then SEGA pulled the plug and they only had the franchises people were pissed about to fall back on.

And yeah - building trust among the community has been Fatshark’s single largest failure.

Yeah but the base situation here was also different. CA hiked all DLC prices by 250%. And rather than just sitting the negative feedback out, one of their CEOs went on a long, unhinged rant that would put John Riccotelli’s monetization speech to shame.
There was no coming back from that but to make a 180 and compromise.

This is probably the only reason DT is still afloat. WH40k die hards already spending thousands on minis. By that metric in game skins are dirt cheap(sarcasm). With the playercount so low and on a severe downspiral, eventually even this will not be enough to cover DT’s running costs.