There are some good reasons for Devs not to individually respond to topics, but Fatshark’s communications overall fail basic Marketing (as a profession) standards.
People will be salty online. Part of communications is handling that. Being able to accept it, being able to separate the useful info from the noise, being able to roll with it and dish it out, etc. That’s what people ostensibly get paid to do. It’s not pretty, but the companies that best respond to this sort of thing do better. If you want to get money out of people, you need to make them want to spend that money, you don’t get to blame them for not giving you money.
If you showcase/promise something for a product and fail to make it happen, that’s on you. You made the value proposition and failed to deliver.
If your concept changes or develops in a different direction for your for-profit software service, and you fail to communicate that fact and people get mad about it, again, you made a value proposition and failed to deliver and that’s on you.
If people get mad at you on message boards for failing to deliver or communicate, that shouldn’t be an excuse to cease communications. People are allowed to be mad about those things as customers of a for-profit software service, negative feedback sucks but it’s important, and if you ignore that your product fails in the marketplace.
If you do something that enrages your userbase, own it and roll with it. Give up something, accept the criticism (embrace it even, become the memes), and keep talking. Otherwise it just becomes an open wound and something for people to pick on.
If your customer base is screaming a coherent message at you around a specific functionality for months (like itemization and crafting) and you steadfastly refuse to even address or talk about it, much less actually do something about it, it’s on you when your customers leave and your product sees declining usage.
If you have offer literally nothing public for future plans regarding your for-profit software service, and drop updated and patches without any news or lead-in, it’s on you when people react poorly and user counts decline.
You don’t get to use these as excuses as to why you don’t communicate if you’re interested in the continued success of your product.
This doesn’t mean Fatshark needs to respond to every post or item, it doesn’t mean they need to take everything posted as gospel, it doesn’t mean they need to cater to any particular user or group or platform, but Fatshark’s current communications and community interaction are failures, simple as, and what people choose to spend their time playing reflects that.
As is, Darktide has lost players every month since launch except for Oct 23 with Patch 13. Player numbers are down 2/3rds from that peak and are down 35% over the last 30 days alone, and over 95% from the launch peak. Other 4-person coop shooters 5/10/15 years old are showing active player numbers 5-10x higher than Darktide and holding far more steady over time and often significantly higher player counts now than at their launch (L4D2, DRG, etc).
There is clearly a problem with Darktide, and Fatshark doesn’t want to talk about it. Whether that’s because they’ve determined they milked the majority of their income at launch already and just relegated the title to Support Mode, or because they have a vision that they just don’t want feedback on, or some other reason, I don’t know, but the problem is real.