Sup everyone, hope you’re having a fantastic day, and if not, I hope it gets better.
So like the title says — what’s the Adeptus Arbites’ identity? What makes it stand out? Because honestly, when I look at the other classes, they can do everything Arbites does, but better. And that’s concerning, because then… where’s its place?
Don’t get me wrong, I love this class. I play it in Auric and Havoc all the time. But the more I look at it now, the more I feel like it’s lost its identity. It needs an update to bring it back up to date with the classes.
Take Ogryn. Even before the update, if you wanted a tank youd bring an Ogryn with taunt and rumbler. Taunt just crowd controls in a way Arbites can’t match. Now the update widens that gap even further.
Or look at Veteran. A plasma gun Vet deletes the exact threats the Arbites is supposed to hold the line throw down shock mines and ypu croud control. Now vet with a few plasma gun shots and krak grenades thats over. Arbites just can’t compete with that.
I wanted to shine light on this because well I like the class bit I don’t want any class to be over shadowed and have a spot in this game no matter the role.
I was watching an old video posted by mister E he made last year and I think he touches on some points still relevant today. I believe the class today doesn’t really have an identity anymore and needs to be touched up I’ll also leave a link for what arbites are for lore needs and new players
Arbites have unmatched durability, a dog to fight autonomously, and insane crowd control potential rivaling that of the Ogryn. They are frontlining tanks who get in and stay in while making sure nothing else gets back up once it’s on the floor. That seems like a pretty strong identity to me.
As an aside, thank you for linking to Lexicanum instead of Fandom, you know what the good wikis are : P
New double barrel castigators will be hype. But they are definitely in need of a bit more variety, I like the dog but the clubs are boring and bullet weapons aren’t great on arbiebs, leaving them with an arsenal that is both extremely small and factually limiting. Hopefully an arbites stubber is on the docket of weapons that could be added.
I don’t know man I feel like it’s identity is disappearing but I think at most I noticing the gap and with the update it’s definitely getting left behind
The Arbites sits in an awkward design position because he’s unfinished, or not what he was meant to be originally.
They were planning some sort of Armoury system for him but it ultimately never ended up in game. Talents like Rebreather, Shield Plates and the Dog bite modifier ones are probably remnants of that.
I’ll be honest, Arbie’s position seems pretty realized to me if his closest comparisons are both the strongest Ogryn and the strongest Veteran at the same time.
I mean, yeah maybe we should be worried since there’s a whole wave of powercreep coming next week but right now honestly happy with his state; could use some new weapons.
Left behind how? Perhaps Arby receiving two small tweaks instead of a whole talent tree rework could be indicative that the devs are satisfied with the state of the class.
Aquila long CD and then it’s Static - this is partially addressed in the new patch - I forgor, the update lets you have it follow you or be static
The old Weapons still suck. Chain Sword, the old Shock Mauls, all of the machinguns (all 3 types), Shredder Autopistol, the old shotguns - simply compare them to class specific Weapons
Other than that, I feel like I can Frontline, Support or play Ranged, and it works well. And it has identity, since other Careers don’t get the safety. You have a source of Stamina. You get free damage by equipping the Arbites unique weapons.
Main build I play is Aquila + Crusher for debuff spam. Been running this on Rotten Armour, with dog. Usually end up doing a lot of Special killing too. Better than the same Support build on Zealot, since you need Crits for Bleed damage increase, whereas Arb just need Staggers, and gets more sources of Stamina.
Other than that, Castigator + AoE Arb Shotgun is bordering on OP, and is extremely fun in corridors.
Yea, you sure? Are we going to pretend like Arbitrator isn’t a ridiculous powerhouse just because it doesn’t have easy access to infinite crowd control & dps?
Arby can perform incredibly strongly, it can deal both great damage and stagger power to act as the sole frontliner in Havoc. It does not need anything extra regarding gameplay performance.
The primary reason why Arbitrator might come across as “outshined” is because Arbitrator was designed like this:
Sits between Ogryn, Veteran and Zealot mechanically and is INCREDIBLY safe to play, which is offset by them having lower potential “highs” than other Classes.
Can choose to either retain their Cyber-Mastiff Companion or get rid of it in exchange for personal buffs with Lone Wolf.
Arbitrator isn’t SUPPOSED to keep up with other Classes in certain regards because that’s just the logical cost of having safer gameplay.
I can support this idea, mostly based on my own experiences trying to play Arby. I’m a very aggressive player and I find them incredibly boring, because their mobility and damage output are somewhat poor. The last time I tried playing them I had to constantly whip out my shotgun to kill elites because you just barely do any melee damage, even when trying to focus all in on the melee bonuses.
Compare this to Hive Scum, which has insane damage output and mobility, but can also explode easily if they eat a random overhead or screw up their positioning. People were saying HS were underpowered on release for that reason, we hadn’t figured out the optimal way to build them and people are bad at video games. But this high-risk high-reward playstyle is also a lot more fun for me.
X and Y aren’t cancelling Z out here, dude. Genuinely HOW does this dispute my point?
Like, OF COURSE an Ogryn is tougher than an Arbitrator. Ogryns don’t have a Cyber-Mastiff or inherent Blitz Regen outside of Big Friendly Rock. There’s give and take between the two and that makes SENSE.
Zealots have Holy Revenant but that also has quite a hefty Cooldown, yet Arbitrators can get back to maximum Toughness and replenish Stamina like CRAZY at literally any point. If you’re getting down to THAT low of Health THAT consistently on Arbitrator, you’re probably doing something wrong.
Ogryns and Zealots also don’t make Enemies count as “Staggered” on all Melee Weakspot Hits, which is a HUGE synergy booster for Arbitrators’ Stagger-based Talents and Blessings.
Exactly. Ogryn is a much better tank because he restores toughness far more effectively by repeatedly clubbing the enemies surrounding him, and he has a larger health pool. Plus, three wounds instead of two give you more room for error. Zealot, in the ‘charge-fatmangus’ build, would probably be more survivable even without Holy Revenant. And with Holy Revenant—especially considering a whopping four wounds—even more so. The only thing is, the Arbites is stronger against Flak Armour when using a shield and charge, but only if the rest of the team is literally right behind his back and covering it, because he gets staggered by every single poxwalker’s hit