I feel like this is the main crux of the ‘issue’ with Terminus Warrant, that makes it feel worse than Weapon Specialist and any other Keystone the Arbite has at it’s respective job.
It’s not a boost to both your weapons playstyles, it’s a boost to your ranged weapon, that’s it. I feel if they changed the penance wording from ‘kills while having the keystone’ to ‘kills while under the effects of the keystone’ suddenly it makes a lot more sense as to where the annoyances and lack luster feel of it come in.
Because on Weapon Specialist, sure it can be annoying sometimes to proc, but basically the same thing you bring up here can be done with weapon specialist. You want to stack up kills and wait to unload a massive hit with high attack speed against a boss? Go for it. You want to get use out of the melee side of in between seeing bosses? it actively lets you do so, and after 1 ammo spent, you get 10 full seconds of guaranteed melee effectiveness, before ever having to think about ‘am I getting any bonus from my keystone?’. And you’re only ever one hot swap shot away from getting full benifits again, even if you want to save the stacks for an unload against a Monstrosity (while still getting the same reload speed and fire rate boost, and crit CHANCE, meaning you’ll actually get a crit verses hoping for one, even if it doesn’t do bonus damage).
Meanwhile, you look at Terminus, and it’s basically just a ranged damage amp with extra steps. You will never have enough melee stacks to ever do anything with past 2-3 swings of said weapon, and the amount of ammo you have to waste to keep up that bonus is obscene, especially given the Arbite has no active way for them to recover it. This thusly results in you just never using your ranged weapon outside of high damage unloads, which at that point, you’re just doing a strictly worse Executioner Order Cosplay.
Because Terminus Warrant gives you:
- 15% ranged damage (other stats largely irrelevant if one’s using a boltgun, and don’t factor into damage besides)
- 15% fire rate (so you’re burning more shots faster and seeing more damage, but no active per shot/ammo conservation increase)
- 25% Critical and Weakspot damage increase, thusly meaning the modifiers for that weapon are increased by that amount, not the damage outright (so in turn the damage actually resulting from these modifiers are drastically lower, verses say, Soulguilt Scan which actually increases strength so the holistic damage increases by that amount).
- 20% reload speed if you take that too (which shouldn’t matter to much since we are looking for an ultra fast melt, but hay you can get back to burning even MORE ammo faster!)
This all compared to:
- 50% Ability Recharge (so your Nuncio-Aquila debuff is ready more often, thusly making it more functional since you can maybe actually have it in the right place to get your burst damage off)
- 30% PERMANENT damage and DR against Monstrosities
- 10% further damage and movement speed on dog pounce (which will happen at the start of most boss engagements, resulting in an effortless melt)
- Further situational buffs occurring based on further talent point expenditure and if you/your dog can get a quick marked elite/specialist kill before hand, not something to rely on but still a further 15% damage amp with 10% crit chance, 25% crit damage and 10% rending on the table in those circumstances.
All of the buffs above applying to BOTH your melee AND your range at any given moment, and staying active through out the entire fight/never falling off no matter how many shots you need to fire or how many hits you need/how many monstrosities you might need to deal with in quick succession (Hi havoc/Auric Mortis Trials later waves), meanwhile Terminus Warrant just gives you Ranged Bonuses effectively…for 30 hits…or effectively 2 mags, that’s it. You get like, maybe 1 swing of melee bonus at any given moment after shooting at a couple specials or elites, and then 2-3 swings after dealing with a monstrosity. Meanwhile the Execution Order Arbite has thrown out more CA’s than you, has done more damage than you, and has a strictly better dog than you.
As you can have up to 40% increased damage with a situational further 15% just for putting the same 4 points in your ability as Terminus Warrant does (assuming you take reload speed) for 15% damage and some minor crit and weakspot bonuses, and the ability to more efficiently waste ammo. This, isn’t really a great trade off to me, especially since you have to ‘waste’ further points grabbing Street Smarts to get to it (though in this case you are probably grabbing it either way regardless to get to Monstrosity Hunter, or going down the right side for Cower, Miscreants! and Target Priority if one values those). Granted as stated you are probably putting points down the middle to get to said monstrosity damage anyway, but at least with Execution Order you have the choice, verses Terminus where it’s required.
There just isn’t much of a reason ever to have Terminus unless you’re actively using both sides, but to do so requires so much ammo investment that you’re basically strictly using it with a Braced Autogun/shotgun or not using it at all. Though I will say I also went the path of looking at Terminus initially and going ‘this will be great for monstrosity melting!’ but after using it for a mission I realized ‘wait…Execution Order is just strictly better for this’, and after I swapped I got better melts AND an overall better experience since the rest of my kit actually functioned along side it, and I wasn’t dumping nearly as many shots/conserving ammo a LOT better.
Thus, I feel this keystone definitely needs help along with OP, I’d personally say though just make it easier to get Melee stacks. Maybe melee stacks are awarded based on the amount of bullets in a mag (so 20 or below you get 5-10 per hit, between 21-45 3-5 stacks, and then 1 stack when at 45+, or something like that). Then the melee side of it can actually be used, and the keystone becomes pretty functional. But for the moment, with it being in it’s ‘basically only a ranged bonus’ state, it’s just E Order but worse.