Game CPU load

At the moment, the game runs(Auric difficulty) at 50-80 FPS on the 5500X3D; using Task Manager and other tools, I discovered that when the frame rate drops, specific CPU cores are pegged at 100% usage, causing the game to struggle - this happens during battles against hordes. Steam lists the 3600 in the game’s recommended specifications, but benchmarks show that the 5500X3D offers significantly higher performance, so there shouldn’t be any performance issues. I’ve tried experimenting with the GPU load, but it doesn’t increase the FPS at all; right now, I keep the GPU utilization at 80–90% to leave some headroom for spikes in load and avoid FPS drops caused by graphics.

Looking back a bit, that 50–80 FPS range might seem sufficient for a comfortable gaming experience; however, the 1% and 0.1% low figures are quite poor at these frame rates. Consequently, the gameplay feels stuttery despite the seemingly adequate average FPS. Currently, this issue is resolved through frame generation, which limits frame rate drops to just a couple of instances per match.

It is worth noting, however, that the game experienced slight performance drops around the time of the latest update and the release of the Skitarii update; while this happens in many games(I mean that games performance drops slightly when updates are released), such incremental declines eventually compound to cause a significant drop in FPS.

For now, the issue is being addressed via frame generation, but I think the game needs optimization to prevent the frame rate from dropping in future updates; if nothing is done, the current downward trend in FPS suggests that playing on the 5500X3D will become impossible within a year or two. Given current PC component prices, I consider game optimization a crucial matter.

Additional information: RX 9060XT, SSD, DDR4 3200 32GB

Just out of curiosity, how many worker threads are you running? I share and totally support what you’re saying, I’ve been trying to find a way to make the game run smoothly for ages now.

FS did a dev blog where they said the nature of the design meant a lot of the logic needed to be sequential and this would come with performance consequences, and as far as I can tell… yeah. Seems like a couple of threads get hit very hard and the game can’t cope. I have logs from 5 different systems and stutter is present in every single one.

Unfortunately FG is a band-aid fix that causes its own problems, and I have very little hope for the kind of extensive work most likely required to resolve this.

Nah, for both of my Intel Nvidia setups performance issues weren’t on the menu until Scum patch happened and the game suddenly took 15 seconds to close and the console logs got 10 times more renderer stalls in it, until that point i was happily thinking myself how nicely optimized the Darktide is!

I am using the maximum number of available threads - something I have obviously double-checked. I am not entirely sure I fully grasp AMD processor architecture, but it seems that the majority of the game’s processes are handled by two cores, which are split into four threads in total. The other cores and threads are also under load during gameplay, but their utilization never rises to the 90–100% range.

Working on optimization is certainly no simple task, but it isn’t quite as difficult as you make it out to be. I’ve seen how this is handled in other games, where performance levels are maintained - or even improved - alongside updates. I believe the developers will address this issue if they receive the right feedback.

For me frame rate drops once in a while with psyker & inferno staff (in my team) & huge amount of enemies at the same time ;]

Try dropping the worker threads to something like 6-8 and see if that helps at all.

I’m running a 9955HX 16c/32t (mobile) but for me the worker threads are set to 8 and I have no issues. I did play around with the value a bit and found that this value works well for me. FPS is stable even under heavy fights even in Havoc with tons of stuff at the same time.

Edit: also I’m using processor lasso to lock the darktide.exe process to just one CCD. This is not relevant for you as the 5500X3D is only a single CCD processor, but if someone else has these issues, this might be of help

We need more information about your game graphics settings.

What resolution do you play at?
Do you have mesh quality set to max or some other value?
Do you use DLSS or FSR, and if so what setting?
Do you pay with ray tracing enabled?
Frame generation on or off?

What about ragdolls, detail levels on particle effects, blood splatter, scorch marks, and so on?

Interestingly I don’t really see renderer stalls at all outside of loading. Past the first 30 seconds of a mission they’re basically non existent for me. Just tons of 20/30ms increases of frametime. and lots of GPU idle power.

I’ll certainly hold out hope that it’s resolvable. If it worked at some point in the past then maybe it is indeed. But I had hopes for the last patch and as far as I can tell no changes were made, and the lack of communication on the topic over years just makes me think they’re in maintenance mode.

In my experience there’s almost no difference as long as I have 6+ threads running. Going below that can make things worse, but higher doesn’t change much.

What are you monitoring with? My average FPS is relatively stable (though lower than I’d like), but the 1% lows are very bad. The reason I ask is I find them very noticeable in Havoc, and they’ve been in every system I’ve tested (5 now). Some of the people using those systems had no complaints and didn’t notice them. I’ve seen people on Youtube say their experience is smooth despite the fact I can see in their steam overlay absolutely catastrophic hitching, and even see it in the video. I hope your experience is stable and I’m very jealous, I’m just kinda at my wits end trying to make it run normally

Dude talks about CPU bottleneck and you ask him to write up about GPU bound stuff…

Just FYI on my GF setup the i7-10700k is bottlenecking her RTX 2070 Super in Darktide, as a matter of fact i’m quite certain that my good old GTX 1060 would have instances of CPU bottleneck with the 10700!

I was merely comparing pre-release and post Scum release logs and the massive increase in frequency and duration of stalls, to showcase how bad that release went

They’re not completely isolated from each other, and even though he says his CPU shows high utilization it doesn’t mean his GPU isn’t a source of some bottlenecks.

I wish it were so, but I’m 99% sure the CPU is the issue. I can increase/decrease graphics settings all day and the average FPS doesn’t move - only power draw. There’s a point pretty much all systems seem to hit around 70 - 90 fps average and beyond that your card is almost irrelevant (provided that you aren’t turning on RT or whatever). There are some small differences, but they’re minimal.

I’ve got FPS meter running and as I’ve limited the game to 120fps it staying there, also the feel of playing (since beta - almost daily) is smooth.
I started out with a desktop 5800x/3070ti, then went laptop 7840HS/4070 and now on a 9955HX/5080.
On all of these systems I’ve messed about with the worker threads and I’ve kept the thread count at half of the cores of the CPU as this has been the most stable way.

What I can attest to also is that game is quite CPU intensive as I can play around with this laptop on how much power I feed the CPU. As feeding the CPU only 30w/40w boost, will reduce the fps quite a lot, even if the GPU is getting 80w or 120w. It will not hit the 120 fps cap even if I give the 120w of GPU power.
Now if I feed the CPU 75w/85w boost with still only 80w going to GPU it will hit 120 fps cap most of the time, but during really heavy fights 80w GPU power is not really enough, but 90-100w is.

Also something to maybe check:
What is your memory usage as if you are hitting 80%+ the game will feel bad. I’ve noticed this due to running ~50+ tabs in Brave + other crap and if I see when in game the memory usage is hovering near or a bit over 80% (with 32GB) I close the browser to drop memory usage. The feel of the game changes quite a lot as it will not stutter as it does with really high memory usage.
(I use HWinfo64 plugin for the Stream Deck to monitor this, but taskmanager will also tell you)

Well its AMD GPU in Darktide so who the hell knows, right? But past that its not buts or ifs, in Darktide the 10700k will idle 2070!

Just to illustrate how absurd it is, the very same GPU that needs undervolting and a custom fan curve in Dune: Awakening just to avoid thermal throttling will happily downclock itself in Darktide while waiting for the 10700!

Ill go out of my way and proclaim Darktide to be in fact insanely well optimized as far as GPU’s are concerned, its the miserable CPU optimization that drags it all down

Yeah fair enough. My average is “smooth” but the stutters just kill my enjoyment of high difficulty and the combat. DT combat is amazing and feels so good, right up until you have a 35ms frame while you’re timing a dodge. I don’t even care that it can’t feed my card at this point, I’d play at stable 90, but it’s just not stable.

Years of playing on weak systems have forced me to develop the habit of closing everything hahaha. I’m not even close to maxxing out my 32gb.

Yeah 100% - when the CPU has room to breathe the game can produce phenomenal frame rates. I’m not even sure the AMD thing is even true anymore either - perhaps there is something there (god knows without the .ini changes it’s painful) but I really think at this point the issues are just universal and are a CPU bottleneck. With the .ini changes both Nvidia and AMD show the same stutter pattern and same low power draw behaviour, and if it were fixed I think both vendors would perform well.

Yop, once you remove Ray Tracing from the equation, Darktide GPU optimization is one of the best i’ve ever seen

I’m not even sure its a real bottleneck or just the all the goddamn buffers making mess of it!

That being said i wonder, have you ever messed around with the direct storage setting in the user_settings.config?

direct_storage = {
disable_bypass_io = false
force_file_buffering = false
}

Btw it doesn’t help that performance issues are seemingly taboo and something to be forcibly ignored by the forum staff, that is in the brief window of time before and after patches when the forum staff deems proper and agreeable to exist…

I know right. The fact that the tiles setting in the .ini file is soo sensitive really raises an eyebrow to what the hell is happening there.

It’s funny you should ask - I haven’t yet, but actually planned to do this tonight. I recently updated my SSD firmware and nuked all the PCIE power saving stuff from orbit. Have you experimented with it? Messing with the storage like a hail mary to me, but I don’t think there’s much left to try.

AGREED. This aspect of it annoys me almost more than the performance issues. I have spent way more time than I would like trying to make this game work and pulling at threads, guessing, all the while there are years old support threads that are silent, and hotfix after hotfix comes by without even mentioning it.

I’m pretty convinced this is the result of decisions made early on and a fix is simply not coming, but the fact they can’t just f****** say this drives me mental. Instead it’s listed as a “known issue” and we’re left poking in the dark. Is it a known issue or is it the result of design decisions? These are mutually exclusive. As it is I think it’s fairly disingenuous and I refuse to buy any of the DLC classes despite really enjoying the game.

I experimented with this parameter but didn’t notice any improvement or degradation. Of course, if the thread count is set too low, performance does suffer. So, for now, I’ve decided to leave it at the maximum value.

I experimented with various graphics settings - lowering them to the minimum and minimizing the number of persistent corpses. I also tried different FSR settings along the way, but none of this yielded a performance boost during combat. In fact, I even raised the graphics settings higher than what I was using before, and the FPS didn’t drop. Whenever performance dips, a couple of CPU cores are consistently pegged at 100% usage.
Right now, I’m playing at 1920x1080 using FSR 4 (with some extra version numbers that don’t really matter here) at native resolution, and I have ray tracing turned off. I’m currently using frame generation, though I’ve tested the game both with and without it. Back when I played on a Ryzen 3600, frame generation actually made performance worse and less stable; now, on a 5500X3D, it makes the game run more smoothly and perform better.
But again, I want to reiterate: I previously tried running(during tests on the 5500X3D) the game with minimum graphics settings - both with and without frame generation - and it made no difference. Now, I’ve comfortably bumped up the graphics settings; the FPS hasn’t dropped, and while stability hasn’t improved, the image quality is much better.

I wouldn’t say I have a real problem right now; it’s more of a concern about a potential future issue if the game’s optimization doesn’t improve. In the past - throughout last autumn, winter, and spring - I played on a 3600 without frame generation. Performance tends to dip slightly after updates in almost every game, and Darktide is no exception. However, over the years, these cumulative drops have become significant enough that the recommended CPU requirements listed on Steam no longer reflect reality.

I’m way past being just annoyed, they release a patch with clear performance hit and can’t even spare a post “yeah, we know and working on it”. A complete Stonewall and have fun trying to somehow work around it on your own!

But you know what? A glitch on a gun is important enough to inform the community about, and even thou they don’t know when they get around fixing it (no problem telling us that), its important to let the community know :+1:

If i was to judge company by a forum staff conduct, activity and a measure of respect to community concerns, Fatshark would be perfect example of a defunct dead company…

I’ve tried when the Scum released but no dice at that time, but it came on my mind again with the last patch. Its always there in the background, gnawing at me and telling me there might be one buffer interaction too many.

Mind you, they purged the directstorage values from user_settings.config so you kinda have to search Axlos (or whats the name) posts on the forum for them, but it should still work!

Pretty sure one of the values in there is just differently named pre-rendering frames setting with a funky enum or somehow tied to it. That’s the one thing i can tell for the ini tweaks with some measure of certainty, the rest does something but F me if i know what it is!

But yeah, i mean i don’t know what i don’t know obviously, but messing around with the ini tweaks and just looking at the file feels like looking at the actual problem

“Oh this buffer has a buffer that interacts with another buff…”

It’s not an issue with your CPU. Try assigning only 8 threads to the game and using the More Graphics Options mod to lower volumetric lighting and similar settings. You don’t need to set everything to the lowest setting; medium or high should be fine.

Also, disable all the FSR, Super Resolution, and other upscaling stuff, and run the game at native resolution. It significantly improves the experience. However, the game still suffers from FPS drops when someone joins the match or when entering the lobby.

I’m not sure if it’s an AMD-specific issue or a general problem with the game, but before the aforementioned patch, the game was running fine.