So, I play on Xbox, aka the land of no macros, no quality of life mods, and much harder head-shots (and a much harder game in general). As such, I have a bit of a skewed sense of weapon use. Given this, the axe gets a bit leg up over some of the other weapons, especially the rapier, as its move-set is easy to learn and you don’t have “trouble” with specific enemies – it will kill everything without having to learn specific move sets or attack patterns, or do any block cancelling. Plus it has a straight-forward move set. Its a great weapon for those new to the game.
I do nudge those who ask toward the flail as its shield-ignoring abilities are great. Most new people have the most trouble with shielded blackrats, and the flail deletes them like no-ones business. In a party if four people, SOMEONE will have horde clear capabilities, but not everyone will specialize in deleting shielded enemies.
Rapier takes waaaay to much finesse on the console for it to be a viable choice outside of the most practiced of individuals.
Again, in every party, SOMEONE will have a horde clear weapon, and because the 2-handed sword has too many disadvantages against armored enemies, I steer people away from that.
Can’t decide? Take teh falchion. Its a solid choice and the best all around weapon.
From above, the game gives you choices when you start out, even on the more rigid, more difficult console. Of course, if the new person gets Ubersreik and grinds out the A&F, all the fun goes away…
(With A&F, take A&F unless you REALLY hate shielded blackrats, then consider flail.)