I’m surprised this wasn’t actually changed yet, with how easy it could be reworked, simply make it…
Uncanny Strikes
“+25% Rending on Weakspot hit” (number can be reduced to 20%, the impotant part is that it’d no longer work by “stacks”)
That’s it, just follow the same logic as Opportunist or Hand-Cannon, applying rending on an attack under X condition
Would it still be picked 100% of the time? Most likely, but at least now it’s a fixed number and not a mess that allows you to make DoT bypass armor nor essentially render armor useless
No matter what the devs do, Uncanny absolutely needs to be nerfed. It is one of the worst meta offenders right now. A damn dueling sword should not be 100x better at dealing with armor than a thunder hammer.
Rapier was also insanely good in VT2 with a correct build. I’m not a fan how those weapons trivialise armour. Even from the setting “fantasy” perspective its pretty silly you would ever pick DS over something like a TH, relic blade or chain axe.
Blessings are in need of a major balance overhaul in general. Many of them are straight up trash, others are class defining. This may pose an issue in itself. Like if you nerf uncanny, you’re killing off half of veterans build variety. It should be nerfed, but these things need to be accounted for.
Vet is the char with inbuilt Rending/brittle so it will be affected the least. For example vet is the only char being able to bring a cat sword into havoc. Besides that there are a number of very good innate penetrating weapons for vet; folding shovels, tac axes, combat axes, shock maul. Which desperately are waiting for a chance to shine.
Edit: and kraks
Yeah, the half of talent variety I mentioned it would kill would be all the builds that dont use kraks or the rending talents. I just think there’s value in having the ability to run shredder and having it not be total ass in the current crusherspam meta. Variety and fun wise I mean. Nerfing uncanny will remove that variety.
Now I’m not saying they need to buff shredders and have uncanny built in because that would just be giving the same builds mroe power for free, but clearly these are real balance problems that need to be worked out, otherwise we end up at an Ogryn situation again. Nerf after nerf and beef up all enemies and now his weapon variety is in the shitter again. I’d hate to see the same happen to Vet. The changes need to be thought out and come in a big balance re-think.
I do not understand. You talk about one interaction on two weapons with one grenade which leaves everything else in the dust… It is one against many hoe is that a loss of variety? And by the way even if shredders do not kill crushers anymore they kill everything else so it would be harder to play because you need proper target prio but it would still be a viable option. Just not as brain-dead as it is now
Well I see it more as pruning overly strong synergies. The build will still be viable just not as screen deleting as it is now. I don’t see how it will be unplayable without the synergy, DS/knife will still be very strong anti-carapace weapons, frags still kill everything else and stun crushers while at it.
Reducing outliers makes non-outliers better in comparison so it will positively effect build variety.
About rebalancing armor: the first step to rebalancing Armor is nerfing uncanny strikes because this blessing effectively removes all and any Armor from the game while active. Any rebalancing done will be void except removing all Armor from the game. Which I deem not a possibility.
I see your point better now, but I think it’s a matter of how viable it is. It’ll be playable, but I don’t think it will be worth picking in any “serious” scenario if you remove uncanny. Because you’d just get swamped by crushers. Which puts it on the level of all the off-meta builds.
I know it’s not that it’s unplayable but I would love if there were multiple very effective builds that play nice with the games meta. Sometimes I play smoke grenade, autopistol and devils claw, and I do have fun doing it, just cause it’s different, but I am seriously and consciously crippling myself and it takes away from it. If I could run this and still be very effective it would be more fun to me. I’d feel forced to play a krak vet in any scenario where I am not consciously crippling myself if they addressed uncanny without also reducing armor spam.
You might be right about it needing to come first though, I just really dislike options being taken away.
I have a similar build with recon las: smokes, shout, 1point in marksman, onslaught and it works crushers beautifully. Just shoot em as you are not running out of ammu😀.