I wasn’t there at that time, only read about it in old forum posts. And though it seems kinda radical, going for another extreme - imo - was also a mistake. Some middle ground should have been found. But I can confidently say that hunting for all those curios made game post-maxing base things much more interesting and enjoyable for me, resulting in me playing it for more hours (not because I had to, I just felt naturally intrigued, I had a goal I could work towards and could actually reach; unlike the alternative sometimes being offered by other types of players, like “gitting gud”, “honing your skills” etc, what, realistically, unachievable in my case).
Different kinds of players need different kinds of stimuluses, it’s not just a theory, it’s a fact as of now, confirmed by decades of data and experience accumulated by hundreds of online games.